Best Italian Food Restaurants in Key West, Florida

1

La Trattoria Restaurant $$
524 Duval St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Seafood Cocktail Bar
Call
2

New York Pasta Garden $$
1075 Duval St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Seafood
Call Website
3

Antonia's Restaurant $$
615 Duval St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Seafood
Call Website
4

La Trattoria Oceanside $$
3593 S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Seafood
Call Website
5

Bel Mare Restaurant $$
700 Front St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Fine Dining Italian Seafood
Call Website
6

Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria $$
516 Fleming St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Pizza Italian
Call Website
7

Onlywood Pizzeria $$
613-1/2 Duval St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Pizza Italian Seafood
Call Website
8

Roostica $$
5620 MacDonald Ave, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Pizza
Call Website
9

Duetto Pizza and Gelato $
540 Greene St #1, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Pizza Gelato Italian
Call Website
10

Onlywood Grill
725 Caroline St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Pizza
Call Website
11

Terrace Roma $$
300 Front St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian
Call Website
12

Lola's Bistro Key West $$
728 Simonton St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Bistros Italian
Call
13

Bruschetta Francesca $$
112 Fitzpatrick St, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Italian Wine Bar
Call
14

Big John's Pizzeria $$
1103 Key Plaza, Key West - 33040
Cuisines: Pizza Italian
Call Website
More options