Penny's Diner

1625 Stillwater Ave, Cheyenne - 82009
193 reviews
Diner American
(307) 778-6620

Just left the drag show at LCCC and we got there at a late time around 11pm Everyone working was so friendly and wonderful for it to get busy on a Friday.Our waitress was top notch.Had three total fresh pots of coffee going and kept our cups full the whole time, on top of helping diners and co-oping with employees working super hard.Our cook did an amazing job on our food.My Frisco was cooked perfectly- French fries were super crispy perfect, and the sausage breakfast burrito with green chili sauce my boyfriend ordered, was on point as well.All was cooked exactly how we ordered it, came to our table promptly and was worth the wait, and I wouldnt expect anything less from everybody there. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Food was average, nothing to make you go there. The staff could care less that you are there. I went in at 5:30am. I was the only person in the place. One young man walking around filling up jellies. I asked for a menu. He said you have to look it up on your phone. One cook doing little things. What I can guess as the owner came in and told the young man to count the register.So I sat for 15 minutes with nothing. Finally I said can I get some food?The cook came over and said what do you want. This guy was not happy to be there. I asked for the biscuits and gravy. He says "we don't have gravy". So I ordered something else. I asked for black coffee. I got one cup and no refills. By this time a couple of customers showed up and got their own coffee.The pancakes were burnt on the bottom. My fork couldn't even cut thru them. The eggs were cold.I went to the register and asked if I could have a cup of coffee to go since I never got a refill. I was told by the owner that it would be charged. I got it and left.This place is ridiculous! No one wants to be there and the customer is bothering them. I suggest going somewhere else.

A really great late night diner experience. We had an incredible and wickedly attentive server, the atmosphere was very comfortable, and our food and drinks were always priority when we were next in line. Thank you for all the hot chocolates!

This was an absolutely horrible experience. I was visiting my brother and We had planned on a quick breakfast as we both had plans later on that afternoon and I had a drive ahead of me. The place was busy but not overly that constituted a long wait. It took me 20 minutes to get a cup of coffee, it was in a dirty cup, and the manager was very rude. We both ordered corn beef hash only to be told 15 minutes later that they didn’t have it, so we both ordered bacon, eggs, hash browns, and toast. We waited an hour, with no sign of our meals and ended up leaving and getting fast food because it was all we had time for.

Absolutely love ,love this 50's dinner! Service was outstanding, and food was fresh, plentiful and delicious!! It's open 24hr 7 days a week. The restaurant was spotless and they draw on the walls!! Something for the whole family to enjoy!!

The waitress is awesome but the cooks are slow. We were the only ones in there, bought Philly sandwiches and fries and we waited over a half hour. But the restaurant is classic 50s. Very cool

The older gentleman cooking and serving was super kind and joy to talk to. Delicious breakfast and a super cute diner.

I like the pick 3 menu item. I easily find 3 items that I like at a fair price. Then add coffee and a water. I am not stuck with the same 3 items until I'm tired of them. Also I can find 3 that fill me up but don't fatten me up. I get cautious, friendly service.

The place was super clean however there was only one person cooking and serving the dinners. Our dinner was seriously overcooked the chicken fried steak patties was so hard you couldn't even cut them with your knife and when they did they chipped off. This was not the fault so much of the cook it was the fault of the facility not having enough staff on hand so that the cook is concentrate on cooking. I watched several people walk in and walk out due to the fact that it would take so long to receive their food. This was truly a bad experience. We paid our bill and left the cook of $4 tip strictly because he was doing the best he could. There were two gentlemen sitting at the counter there I assume they were there to check people in and out their hotel room and neither one of them offered to help the cook at all. If I go back and discover that there's only one person they're working hell I'm just going to leave it is not worth it this used to be a nice little hidden place to eat it has now gone strictly downhill.

We took our family here while passing through, thought it looked like a cute atmosphere and would have options anyone could select from. They were not busy, and yet it took an hr and a half to get food! There was one waitress, one cook. And most the time she sat on her phone behind the desk, she made the Malts, then never came back to check if we needed anything! To top it off the food wasn't good. Would not recommend at all.