Mary's Mountain Cookies

315 W Lincolnway, Cheyenne - 82001
94 reviews
Dessert Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
(307) 514-0404

Great ice cream flavors, love the lemon cookie, a bit too expensive. We must limit our visits.

Gluten Free!!!! Had the snickerdoole and the orange doodle gluten free cookies. SO. VERY. GOOD. Had to go back the next day and get more. Soft and chewy. Tastes great! (Not a cheap cookie but very good).

Flavors are there but they’re all underbaked and taste raw. If you’ve got gastric issues or are an at risk demographic, you may get sick.

This place is amazing. The cookies are some of the best I’ve ever had. We are in Cheyenne for 4 more days and I know we will be back to grab more before we leave.

I truly; really wanted to appreciate the generous size of these yummy-looking cookiesㅡ but sadly these are just yuck. Not only is it a bit pricey, but just in general, these are terrible. I’d go as far as to say store-bought cookies are tastier than these cookies. Would highly advise NOT coming here sadly.. :(

Before yesterday, our experience was good here. I ordered two dozen cookies to pick up later this week. I understand they got busy, but when I went to pay, I asked about their special the gentleman told me about, and the lady that rang me up told me it is not available. Regardless, I need the cookies, but I felt like she rushed me because they got busy after we walked in.

Everyone is friendly and the cookies are awesome! My favorite is the Chai cookie! I can't wait for it to come back.

The have excellent cookies. They have gluten free cookies that are yummy too. The cookies are large and so good you need to buy more than one. . You'll regret it if you don't. The staff is wonderful, as good as the cookies.

Cookies are SO DELICIOUS! Orange doodle and salted caramel are my faves. Reasonable prices. Super friendly.

The cookies at this place or absolutely amazing.