Sal's Pizzeria

161 N Main St, West Bend - 53095
161 reviews
Pizza
(262) 334-3944

Great specialty pizza by the slice. Very similar to a pizza place with a few locations downtown but Sal’s blows it out of the water.By far the best Mac & Cheese pizza I’ve ever had. Slices are reasonably priced and so many to chose from. Added bonus, the garlic dough balls come with the pizza!I would highly recommend

I am kind of new to area and have been trying to find a good local place for good pizza, this is one of the best so far.

Best pizza by far and away in the area. Great selection. But what makes this place SO good is the crust. Very New York style. Not super thin but not thick. Just perfect. Brian and Josh behind the counter are great and friendly. If you aren't getting your pizza from here you are wrong.

I used to love the pizza from here but it has been going down hill. I ordered my pizza to be well done and I have an undercooked floppy crust. I probably won’t be ordering from here anytime soon.

Great garlic knots! And so kind!We came in late from the airport and nothing was open. The kind cook at sals gave us 4 garlic knots for a snack because everything was closed including sals. So kind! AND THE GARLIC KNOTS ARE AMAZING! There are kind people in the world. We thank you. This a person I would want working for me and representing my company. I’ll be back to order dinner and get his name. My brother lives here and highly recommends too!

Ordered pizza for delivery from well outside their delivery area, they gave us a very reasonable delivery charge and showed up in less than an hour with a very friendly delivery driver. Food was great 5 stars.

Best pizza in town. Hands down. Just the crust makes it the best. Sauce seasoned right. Cheese blend A+. It’s the only pizza we get now. Someone could offer me a free pizza and if it wasn’t Sal’s I couldn’t take it. Rather donate that stuff and buy a Sal’s

This is my husband and I’s favorite pizza stop. We love the Gyros, Gyro pizza, Baked Potato pizza, Lasagna pizza, and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. Even more we absolutely enjoy the customer service the ownership and staff that are always present give us each time we stop in (usually once a week ?). Customers for life! Thanks Sal’s pizza! ?

This is my husband and I’s favorite pizza stop. We love the Gyros, Gyro pizza, Baked Potato pizza, Lasagna pizza, and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. Even more we absolutely enjoy the customer service the ownership and staff that are always present give us each time we stop in (usually once a week ?). Customers for life! Thanks Sal’s pizza! ?

Fantastic New York style Pizza. The crust had just enough crispness and tenderness to crackle when you fold it in half. The Garlic roll comes with it and Id add a marinara sauce for dipping. They also warm up your slice before serving in the pizza oven. I'll be back many times for sure. Highly recommend this place for great Za.