Love these pizzas and the service!
This is hands down the BEST pizza in Wisconsin. The sides are all fantastic, the marinara sauce is definitely home made and has fresh basil in it. The boneless wings are perfectly crispy, and fried mushrooms are spot on. They usually have a long wait time for pick up, but it is 100% worth it.
We ordered and waited two hours for our food. We made one call and asked about the delivery time, got left on hold, and when they returned to the call they had no answer. We were put on hold again and afterwards they said they “didn’t know what to tell” us, and then they hung up on us. We feel that the customer service is extremely lacking, and would be significantly better if they were more understanding and could at least provide a rough estimate.
Hello!!Not only is this my FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE!! Best Pizza in Townnnn by far!!! But they also treat customers with the up most respect:)When I attempted calling and ordering online yesterday evening to pick up dinner after my work shift, the system seemed to be down. So working under Customer Service myself, I completely understood that Technology can treat us hot or cold sometimes;)…. Well, I was CRAVING their pizza so bad… I walked in person to order:) The debit machine was not picking up my card, so the Cashier who was assisting me, went to his phone to transact the transaction with a Square Card Method, This was the last option in paying for my order, and he did not want me to leave disappointed after my many attempts to order! Well, he did just that and completed my order!!! I was sooo excited and happy that he went through hoops during their busy, dinner time to make this dinner happen!!! On top of his kindness, his ambition to make the whole Pizza Place smile was beyond amazing!! I love everyones energy in there! They really mark their Business with a Gold Star!! Impressive:) The quality of the Pizza is exceptional and leftovers for lunch are even better:) Keep Being Amazing!!!
Awesome local pizza! The pizza, breadsticks, salads...etc are *chefs kiss*Called ahead for delivery as I know it's busy on SuperBowl Sunday. Staff were really friendly and helpful, our order arrived right on time!
Breadsticks - to die for.Stuffed pizza and regular pizza - awesome.Lasagna - left something to be desired. It was really watery.My only real complaint is we were quoted an hour to pick up; my husband got there at about 65 min and still had to wait 15 min in the restaurant. I know those stuffed pizzas take forever to bake but I'd rather be quoted a longer time than having to wait in the restaurant.Still one of the best pizza places in Stallis.
This pizza is awesome! Def will be back. Featured here is a stuffed meat lovers with mushrooms! The sauce is a mix between sweet and savory, really nice. The wings were ok too. Definitely will be back
Pizza has way to much cheese. Almost everything slid off of my husband's pizza. The fried garlic bread was super salty. We didn't even know what it was at first. It looks like it was barely fried. Wings were good but a little salty. My kids and did not enjoy our pepperoni pizza. Cheese was already cooled down which gave the pizza a rubbery texture. My daughter was able to pull the toppings and crust apart. We just overall, were not satisfied. Our total was super high. Should have been a lot less for the garbage we got.
Great thin crust pizza an deep fried bread sticks. Always call in your order to make sure you get an accurate time on when the pizza will be done. If you wait to long to call, expect an hour plus long wait. The pizza is worth the wait everytime.
Wow what a surprise! I have lived in this city my entire life and never been to Scottys before. The pizza was fantastic! Perfectly baked, with lots of cheese,, and awesome flavor. Will definitely be back!