Pegasus Restaurant

7727 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis - 53214
207 reviews
Greek American
(414) 774-4828

Yummy food and great service. Great for the whole family!

We had a group of 12 and had a wonderful experience. The gentleman who greeted and seated us was very quick and accommodating. Our waitress, May, was very attentive and kept the food coming and our drinks full. Very kind and thoughtful. The food was good portions and most of our food came with salad or soup, and a potato choice.There was a nice variety of options for adults and kids alike. The steaks, shrimp fajitas, and gyros were all very good. Our dinners also included desert which we took to go. I definately recommend this establishment and will return again when in the area.

Stopped for a light breakfast. Booth was available, and waitress was already standing by, to see if we needed coffee.Place was clean, and the eggs I ordered were great.Waitress was cordial, and did keep our coffee full..

My son who is disabled went with his grandma today and they had the worst service. The waitress totally ignored their presence and brought their food cold, didn't ask if they needed anything... passed right by them when they were refilling other people's coffee, the bad service goes on. I completely understand that this is a pandemic and short staffed is everywhere but you've got to learn to respect other people and serve people the way they deserve.

Large menu, breakfast served all day.. Never had a disappointing meal there. One of my favorites is the House Special -- 3 eggs, 3 pieces of toast, gyro meat, and hash browns or American fries

Awesome family owned & operated business! Value for the $ is crazy!!! The older woman that was our server was phenomenal. She cared and was very hardworking. Reminded me of my Greek grandmother. The food was huge portions and included a soup or salad and desert. We enjoyed it so much that we ate here both nights that we were in town. Everything we got was good. Ribs, pasta, waffles, soups, etc. All good. Chicken parmesan was my favorite. Only thing I'd like to see is the place modernized/decor changed up, but that costs money and I understand that could cause price increases! Just be ready to be taken back to the 1990's! Haha I will certainly be back.

Moved from Milwaukee to DePere a year ago & missed this restaurant & the people. We have a new fave up here, but visiting my grandson today & the only place we all wanted to go was Pegasus. With the first bite of food, I smiled & said mmmmmmmmmm! Food so good & the really nice thing was they remembered all of us even though it was over a year since we'd been there!! Big place, but always so homey & had attentive staff even tho they were busy. Will always be our go to when we're in Milwaukee!!

Went for late lunch.Great food and service

We went to Pegasus last night. First time. The service and the food was excellent. Will definitely go back again. Very comfortable atmosphere too.

Always enjoy coming here!!! Staff are friendly fast and always helpful!!! The food is always tasteful and perfectly hot!!! hope this restaurant never goes out of business!!!!