Jimmy John's

2911 S 108th St, West Allis - 53227
98 reviews
Sandwich Shop Fast Food
(414) 541-9999

If you love Jimmy Johns, this location is like the Hall of Fame for best workers and bread. The bread is slightly undercooked, leaving you with a soft, decadent bread with a crispy underside. The mayo isn’t too cold; it’s the perfect temperature. Crispy lettuce and juicy, fresh tomatoes ties my #4 Turkey Tom together, and they never miss. They hand me my sandwich with reverence, ensuring that my #4 Turkey Tom is in the right hands. The best sandwich that I’ve ever had the honor of eating is even better with a refreshing, cold Minute Maid lemonade. Prefect straws that never bend accompanied by crunchy Salt and Vinegar Jimmy Chips bring tears to my eyes. I’ve never felt so loved sitting in a sandwich joint. The pickle (quartered) was the best thing I’ve literally ever tasted. Shoutout to Lance for taking my order with care and a friendly smile! Thank you Jimmy John’s!

Excellent unwitch... super fast. I so appreciate their hard effort!!

Best jimmys I have ever been to. The bread was SO soft and delicious and the refreshing lettuce and tomatoes from the turkey tom was heavenly. Not to mention, the quartered pickle was life CHANGING, as it was extremely juicy and tasty. The sweet chocolate chip cookie tied the meal together, perfecting this jimmy experience. This jimmys isn’t like the rest. The food is at another level!!! I highly recommend this specific location and also the turkey tom add pickles??????

Did an online order they messed up the extra toppings not happy cost 4$ more for a standard sandwich

I ordered and the delivery guy spilt my drank all on my sammiches but luckily the rest of the staff is awesome!!!! Hooked me up. Will remain ordering Jimmy's from this location for sure!

Had an attitude when I asked for a "Ham sandwich" and the 1st one had cheese on it and they had to make another 1.

Sandwich artist was not wearing gloves and caught an attitude when asking to put them on. He said his hands were clean and did not need them. Will not be returning

We dined in the subs were delicious. Plus ,they have different flavored chips and soda.

I am so shocked by the experience I just had! As the manager told me, I have 14 previous orders with them. Which al have turned our perfect and delightful. However today, I placed my order online like I always do and the website must have malfunctioned. So I call down to the store once I noticed my order was messed up, and ask if they could fix my order please? The girl who answered the phone was very kind and polite, she told me she needed to grab the manager, so she did. When the manager got on the phone is when everything went south. And honestly he was probably having a bad day. But I explained to him the situation, and he said to me, "So you want me to fix the order that our website messed up?" I questioned, "Yes, that was I am asking you to do." He quickly informed me, "I cant do that, every order that gets messed up by the website if I remade their order I would be loosing thousands of dollars a day! Call the cooperate number, they can help you." I told him, "Okay, so my order that I ask for the SAME WAY the last 14 times you cant fix, even if its your WEBSITE in the wrong!? You know what, I just wont order from you again." He said, "Wait, you wont order from us because our website messed up your order!?" I was shocked at this point, "NO!? I wont order from you again because you talked to me like a piece of trash who is trying to scam you, disrespected me, and wont help out a customer who has been faithful to you guys for a long time!" *Click* He hung up the phone. Jimmy Johns, I love your food, and I know this is that manager. I will not return to this location. I will be contacting corporate as well.

Awful place with terrible delivery standards wont deliver to a place 15 blocks away because of their arbitrary delivery service area. Id give them 0 stars if i could.