Firehouse Subs Mayfair

1701 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa - 53226
143 reviews
Sandwich Shop Fast Food
(414) 930-9300

Tried the Tunafish on the Italian and it was delicious! I've heard the tuna here was great and I'd definitely agree to this! Comes with a pickle and I also had the Chicken & Dumpling Soup, very delicious also ? the two guys working were awesome too ??

This was the first time we ever had fire house subs and it will be the last time. They are not worth the money, the bread is so dense with no flavor, I had two tomato slices, I had one single ring of an onion on each tomato slice, did not see any melted cheese. The ham on my club had a good flavor by itself, the bacon was flimsy and not crispy and the mac & cheese cup was a little over half full, Definitely not worth the money. The husband said his sub had a good amount of meat (way more then mine did) but no flavor and the bread was tasteless. He said it was like eating mush.

Very slow the workers are too busy watching TV to make your food! Ordered 3 subs and was the only person there took more than 20 minutes.... to add on to that threw sandwiches away they didnt taste good a waste of $30! Never Will I go here again!

Delicious subs! I love this location too, they always have great portions and great quality. You definitely get what you pay for. Yum!

Very dissapointing! Ordered soup, it wasn't even warm. Missing beverage, Missing pickle spears, wrong chips, sandwich missing Italian dressing which is EXTREMELY important for an Italian sub. I was hoping this would be my stop before work, nope, won't be back.

Great sandwiches, great customer service, always clean.

This place has great subs and salads! I highly recommend Firehouse to everybody..

The subs are almost always delicious, but the service can be so slow sometimes. I understand times are tough right now, but I placed an online order for 6:25 pm, didn't receive my order until 6:40 pm, and the subs were only lukewarm.

Ordered here on 12/31 there were zero customers in the store and I stood there untill the manager came out to tell an employee to serve me. I did not receive what I ordered. I did not get a pickle with either sandwich and my sandwich barely had and meat on it (approximately 4 slices of meat compared to my SO's sandwich which looked normal). Staff doesn't want to be there and makes the customers suffer. Extremely disappointed and will not return to this franchise again.

Love it can't wait to come back food was A-mazing ..workers were very friendly and nice...