Tally's Tap & Eatery

S31W24661 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha - 53189
119 reviews
Bar & Grill American
(262) 446-3153

Good quality food but has been cold the last few times we've been there. (Windows open or the AC cranked up) Bring a sweatshirt... no joke.

We met up with some friends based on their recommendation. What a cool place, the menu was very well balanced and being a bit of a foodie my expectations are higher. My dinner was AWESOME and the drinks were well crafted. Overall it was a fun time and would recommend you pay them a visit. Also, the staff is Top Notch!!

Went with group of six. Food was good, server was excellent, but they missed one burger on the order and it didn’t come out until almost everyone else had finished their meal. They did give us a drink chip for the inconvenience. Still a great place to go with lots of different food options, appetizers, pizzas and sandwiches.Just a note that they do charge a credit card fee on all meals when using credit card, so you may want to bring cash.

First time visiting here and so glad we found the place.Great food and easy to watch the game.A little noisy but not too bad. Family friendly and we noticed on the way out a second bar, need to check into that next time.Biggest issue is parking. Definitely an issue here. We park what I would say is a couple block down the street.Plan ahead of you someone who has trouble walking in your party.We will be back.

Been to Tally's more times than I can count and never leave unsatisfied. Tonight was a busy, rainy Saturday there. We went with our 3 kids (all under 5 yrs old) and were treated very kindly by staff and other diners. The fajita wrap is so darn delicious (my fav thing on the menu), and their tally fries are unique and tasty. And their stuffed pretzels and pizza- both so good! It's louder than average and although we love sitting at the bar, the restaurant atmosphere isn't the greatest. But we go back time and time again. Thanks, Tally's Team for providing this community with a great place to dine!

I am lucky enough to work across the street and can frequent there often. all of their food has been delicious really generous portions and something for everybody including my picky children. highly recommend any and all of their pretzels as well as their fish fry.

Amazing service, lots of food options. Check for the pretzel of the week. This week was bananas foster cheese cake. There is handicap access to main dinning room but has a sharp corner at the entrance.

Was surprised that we were seated right away being that they were so crowded...tha food was quite good...will definitely go back

The patty melt was great. We upgrade to the parmesan fries OMG they were the best! Great atmosphere and the service was wonderful. I loved the Bloody Mary, it was awesome! We'll be back!

My husband and I had a wonderful time here. The menu options were impressive and we had a hard time choosing what to get. They also had excellent specials today. Service was great and the overall vibe of the restaurant was very inviting.