This restaurant was such a disappointment. First of all, I called in an order and the girl on the phone was rushing me and ended up getting my order wrong. They didn’t give us the two fries we ordered. The Mr. T sandwich we ordered was supposed to be a steak sandwich but it had two dry hamburger patties instead. The menu online sounds very appealing however the food does not match up at all. It had no flavor whatsoever. Everything was dry. My jerk chicken salad was a few dry pieces of chicken on a few pieces of lettuce. Nothing special. When my husband went to pick up the food, he said the place is just a bar so literally all you are going to get from here is bar food. It was very obvious everything was just frozen food thrown together. Kind of grossed me out while I was eating it. We are visiting Sheboygan from out of town for our anniversary. Tonight was our first night here. This dinner was a huge let down. I am attaching a picture of theMr. T which is supposed to be an 8 oz steak sandwich which is literally just two hamburger patty’s in a dry bun. So bad.
Always have an awesome time and the food is great!
Service was fair although forgot items that were ordered. Ask questions if you are going for all you can eat fish, unless they change the menu. Maybe the locals know but visitors don't. "All you can eat fried cod (also available perch, walleye, white fish)" To all of us it read any of these types of fish. So we got Walleye because it's not common. The dinner had 1 piece of fish, when tried to get more told wasn't all you can eat. Which then made the price paid per dinner for 1 piece of fish not the best either. We were not told the potato salad was German and not a "regular" cold potato salad. The potato pancakes were ice cold rounds of previously fried hashbrowns.
Excellent fish fry’s and the Mr T steak sandwich with fried onions is a Sheboygan legend that can’t be beat Can’t go wrong with the food here
Good Food and friendly staff
The food was excellent, met the owners Thursday night and Friday night very polite, took time to talk with us both night. Thank you
FOAK never disappoints! Great people, great food, great drinks!!
For a genuine Midwest experience, come here. Not only can you get traditional Wisconsin bar food, but you can get Pasties traditional to the UP. The bartenders are amazing and so is the food. I can't say enough about the Ranieri family and this place. If you come to Sheboygan, and only have time for one meal.....set your Waze to Ranieri's Four of a Kind and prepare yourself for the best REAL Sheboygan food, period.
Always great service. Food and drinks were great
It's your standard issue bar food. Not terrible, but nothing special. Nice atmosphere.