First time ordering from Nicky's and wasn't disappointed. Pizza was hot and very good!Delivery on time. Will order again!
Pizza was either undercooked or it’s just not the same Nicky’s pizza I once thought was good as hell.
Amazing thin HOMEMADE crust! BEST PIZZA IN SHEBOYGAN!
The worst I have ever had! Raw veggies and a rude manager. I do not recommend for anything!!!
Waited 2 hr and 15 mins. Got hung up on after calling for status. Came and it was all wrong/cold. Ugh never again. Used to be a fave.
Pizza was delicious. The cheese bread was good as well. It came hot and the delivery driver was great also.
AMAZING pizza!!!!!! Gigantic large with tons of toppings! The BLT is out of this world perfect!
Me and my husband did a taste test between Faye's and Nicky's Faye's had about out of the 16 about half the pieces didn't have sausage. I feel that the sauce and sausage is way more flavorful. If you have a choice choose Nicky's.
It's a beat up place and not clean. But the food was good. They also messed up my order, gave a pizza instead of a pie and said they don't make pies anymore. I ordered via Google though.
I don't normally leave reviews but I will NEVER pick up an order or order personally from this restaurant again. There was one staff that was completely out of line and was super disrespectful- said something unnecessary and told the staff member (the one waiting on me - very nice) - in an obnoxious tone "they can wait - IT'S THEIR JOB TO WAIT - we hav other orders to crank out!" As if my order was less important or didn't count. It is NOT my job to wait! This was completely Uncalled for - disgusted with this persons behavior professionally. THAT IS THE WORST EXPERIENCE I'VE HAD at ANY restaurant. I have never walked out so fast in my life.