Ordered delivery. For the price it was not horrible but not spectacular either. The meatloaf was a bit dry, glad i had ketchup at home. Baked potato was good. Ribs were quite good but the mashed potatos tasted like cafeteria dehydrated potatos. Soup a bit salty. The mornay pasta dish had noodles sticking to each other, and the scallops should have been seared first, they were fairly rubbery. A lot of potential...a few drinks would have helped :)
Great food friendly reasonably priced food had a great price
Classic pub and cozy atmosphere. Staff were incredibly accommodating and friendly. Jeff’s is a fantastic neighborhood joint.I stopped in for the AYCE Whitefish dinner and it totally hit the spot. Haven’t had fish like this in a long time!Whatever your reason for stopping in, you’ll be well taken care of. So sit back, relax, and stay a while.
For no good reason I can consider I've never eaten here in the 29 years I've lived in Oshkosh. Very nice and attentive staff, very decent old fashioned, and the ribeye Oscar was delicious. Will definitely return soon. Kicking myself for not going sooner.
Ordered fried chicken dinner to go it was Fabulous!!They forgot the plastic ware but the food was sooo good I barely noticed?Definitely will be back when I'm in town again
First time I have been here. Food was great, service was fast and good. Definitely will visit again in the future
My wife and I decided it was worth sharing this review. Unfortunately, despite a decent atmosphere and good service, the food is simply not worth returning to. I genuinely think that the fact most people drink before they're sat has something to do with all the positive reviews. The bread they serve is delicious, the Old fashions are good, but I've never had food without taste. We seriously thought something was wrong with us. The fried fish literally had no flavor, my Prime rib...which I love generally, had zero taste. Also had more fat on it than I've ever seen anywhere else. The only detectable flavor was black pepper. I had to add salt which I've never done for prime rib. The potato wedges and mashed potatoes were all equally bland. Bummer. We ate what we could and brought home the left overs, next day sure enough...still no flavor yet everything else we ate did. We seriously gave this place a couple shots the last few months, but are back to putting it aside. Wouldn't recommend, unfortunately.
Austin Gross was amazing. Very professional and helpful.
Haven’t been to a fish fry in at least a decade. We don’t have them on the west coast. An Uber driver recommended Jeff’s. So glad I followed his recommendation. Everything was outstanding! If I can only make a fish fry every ten years, I’m so glad this is where I went!
My wife and I ordered food from here for the first time. The guy taking our order over the phone was a bit rude, but the bartender was very sweet. My wife's salmon was dry and my "medium tenderloin" was very chewy and not melty or tender like a tenderloin is supposed to be. I'd say it's tied with ground round for the least tasty tenderloin I've ever had from a restaurant. The coleslaw was delicious. Overall, we were very underwhelmed and won't be going back again.