Oh my deliciousness yummy yummy yumminess the service excellent, food excellent, vibes excellent and parking was a great day. I had crab cake, shrimp cocktail, cod dinner and shared shrimp dinner. Everyone loved their food. I love that I can get a fish dinner on any day of the week. Weekdays are easier than Friday night. Highly recommended! Off street meter parking. Bar outside and inside yes go meet some friends and enjoy!
Really good experience here. Waitress was kind. Food was visually pleasing and super delicious! Would come back just to eat the lobster roll again ?
Perfect lunch spot. Fresh shucked oysters. The fried perch sandwich was excellent. The salmon jerky was strange but surprisingly good. Lobster roll was quite fresh and good. No complaints. Casual.
I'm a guide for one of the Milwaukee food tours and one of our stops is St Paul's Fish Company for their Fish Fry. When I ask guests at the end of the tour which stop was their favorite, this fish is a consistent winner. It's so fresh and breaded perfectly. Portion size is very healthy too. Come hungry.
The St. Paul Fish Company in the Milwaukee Public Market is pretty dang cool. The market is located in the historic Third Ward adjacent to the downtown business district. We were there on a busy Sunday, but found a place to eat just outside the door. The wait was minimal, and they page you with a buzzer when the food is ready anyway. They sell an amped up lobster roll on a garlic toasted brioche. It has shredded lobster and sizable chunks of lobster meat with plenty of seafood seasoning. It's a good value because it comes with a decent helping of fries and a small cole slaw. It's almost enough for two people with an appetizer or something. The crab cake is tasty, but it's only one medium portion. There is a big selection of fresh seafood available as well as prepared dishes including the Wisconsin Fish Fry, hey. I don't see any way around getting that lobster roll on every visit. It's a, see food; eat food, thang.
Food was absolutely delicious, but the Salmon Crack was so fantastic we bought some extra to take with us!! We had the Crab Cake, Salmon Crack & Fish Tacos, all were delicious! Wish I lived closer so I could visit more often!! Love the Milwaukee Public Market they are located in!
We went to the Milwaukee Market for my son's 15th Birthday. What a wonderful experience. So many treats and goodies! The oyster bar gave him 2 free oysters before we ate dinner. The lobster roll sandwich has been on my 'must try' list so we ate at St. Paul fish market and the owner went out of her way to make sure we were taken care of. When we finished dinner, the owner sent over a cupcake with a candle and sang Happy Birthday! We really appreciate your kindness and caring. This was such a nice and fun experience. The food was outstanding. Really large portions and very tasty, everything cooked to perfection. Thank you!
I have had some of the best seafood here. I started off with some fresh oysters on the half shell and probably one of the best Bloody Marys ever that was topped with a lobster tail, smoked fish (salmon or trout) and a shrimp. And my lunch was half the Cajon roll and half the lobster roll. All really incredible and I will definitely be eating here again.
Stopped in while walking around the Public Market. Glad I did! Enjoy the steamed clams and lobster roll was among the best I’ve ever had. Full of tasty goodness, and excellent bread. Coleslaw was good too. Really enjoyed this restaurant and would recommend it. Period
By far the best and fresh seafood I have experienced in Milwaukee! Loved every bite of my generously filled lobster roll. Fresh and delicious Walleye was another gem. Not greasy or over breaded. My son order grilled shrimp taco and he graded them A+. Overall great experience!!!