We made a reservation here for two, and when we got there they asked if it's okay if we get sat at the pizza bar. At first we were hesitant, but it turned out to be so much fun to watch the pizza artists at work. It was like dinner and a show :) Cheesy, I know. Aside from the entertainment, we split the burrata and the Ilario pizza. The burrata was perfectly creamy, the olive oil was flavorful, the salt came through but not too much, and complimented the sweet ripe tomatoes perfectly. The pizza was also great! I wish the bottom was cooked just a touch more since there was a little bit of dough goo in the middle, but the flavors were great. The San Marzano tomatoes that SG uses for their sauce make a huge difference and add such a wonderful brightness to the pie. Go to San Giorgio and ask for a reservation at the pizza bar!
Very pretty restaurant in Downtown Milwaukee that has a modern aesthetic. Ordered 3 pizzas and Caesar Salad for takeout. Pizzas were excellent, but pricey. Definitely high quality so I do not feel I overpaid, but this is more expensive than many other pizzerias. The salad was a bit disappointing because the romaine had started to wilt / go brown. The staff was very nice as I dealt with two women - the hostess and a bartender. I highly recommend if looking for pizza downtown or a special night out, but too expensive to be an every week place.
We sat at the chef’s counter. Everything was amazing from the service to the food. We shared the burrata, and got two different pizzas and finished with the tiramisu. I highly recommend! It was a great tasting experience.
Dinner for two at 5:00 pm. We had a reservation and it filled up pretty quickly. Service was good and the food was prepared well a property seasoned. The only thing that could have been impproved upon is that the thin center part of the pizza was Luke warm. Possibly because of the plate being cold? The pizza was still delicious, just could have been hotter. The meal with an app. Salad and a pizza plus 4 glasses of wine was $95. We would certainly dine here again
While in Milwaukee for a Bucks game last night. My son and I had the pleasure of staying across the street from this amazing place. The food was fantastic on all levels, and the staff was delightful! I am already planning my next 4 hr drive to Milwaukee, just to eat here again!
Exceptional pizza, service, and ambiance.
My Neapolitan pizza was soggy! I told the waitstaff and they said they are award winning and that is the way it is served. I’m sorry but in Naples Italy contrary to what they say.. the pizza is crispy! Also $12 for a very small bowl of minestrone with chicken.. I don’t think so!!
Our pizza arrived soggy and dripping wet with oil. When I attempted to speak to our waiter about it, he assured me thats traditional Napoli pizza. I'm not sure where in Naples Italy he has had such an awful pizza, but not there!!! No way to fix it we were told its made that way on purpose. Run as fast as you can elsewhere!!!!
A great tasting pizza, friendly staff, and good vibes! Will definitely recommend!
Amazing food. One of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. Highly recommend, great atmosphere.