Pizza Crafters

N56W15560 Silver Spring Dr, Menomonee Falls - 53051
157 reviews
Pizza Salad
(262) 781-9400

I normally come there a lot and for the first time I brought three friends with me and we were about to get some salads and there was a ton of fruit flies does soda machines need to be clean because that’s where all the fruit flies come from

Not the best pizza ever, but it's still pretty good. The bread is very good. Also, it's an excellent value. You get a lot of food and variety for the money.

The lady at the front counter made me feel super welcome right off the bat! Very reasonable price for a delicious Buffet with all sorts of different items including a great salad bar pizza dessert and soda. Love this place, will be back !

Stopped in yesterday for the first time. Great salad bar and out-of-sight pizza! Everything was spanking clean and the help was friendly and attentive. Hope to return soon.

Only purchased the Bavarian Pretzel, this was my first time coming here, the hostess was very nice and my order was ready by the time I arrived. I ordered on their website which could be laid out a little better, but overall I had a very good first experience.

It was pretty good. I don’t really have any complaints. It is much better than Pizza Hut, but not quite Pizza Ranch. I enjoyed the various available selections of pizza, plus you could request your own. They had a salad bar, nacho bar, and dessert bar. Overall I would give it 4.5 stars, but Google makes me choose between 4 or 5. I’d happily come back again.

Superb pizza and salad bar, with an excellent mix of pizza selections that changes each time you come back for more. My favorite was the stuffed crust nacho, with a nice little bite to it, but the Supreme with a tasty mix of fresh ingredients gives it a good run for the #1 spot on my list. With all of these all-you-can-eat choices (and I haven't even mentioned the fabulously fresh selection of items for the salad I started with), you might be tempted to stuff yourself, but remember to save a couple bites for dessert: I'd happily spend a morning putting myself into a sugar coma with a pile of their cinnamon bites, if they ever open to serve these for breakfast! Great food for a good price.

Nice and friendly people (maybe owners but not sure) both as I was greeted and working behind the bar. Restaurant was clean and comfortable and the food was very good. Will definitely recommend this place to others.

Been going here for years. It always fills me up! Lots of options to choose from, but sometimes I wish they could change the pastas every now and then. Overall great place and vibe.

I took my kids and grandparents here at 1pm on a Tuesday for lunch. When we came in, I was ready to leave immediately when I seen every table - was terribly dirty. I felt I had driven all this way so I told the desk person of this issue and proceeded to pay over $50 for all of us (5 people). We found a spot prior that was near a section of what looked like a workspace. The buffet was very scarce and I asked if they will ne making more food. I was told that they were slow and they weren't going to make any more for an entire section. (See in photos). I said that if I am to come in and see an empty buffet, how will I try the food? They said they had garlic sticks and was fine with that. After they started making more pizzas and asked what we would like to try, which was nice. I Said again if I could try the macaroni and seems I was getting excuses of why the staff didn't want to make any. I came back and seen there was one compartment filled (macaroni). I took back to try and it was cold :(. Salad bar was good. You have to clear off your own table of plates, and probably end up cleaning your table before you sit also. When we were leaving, they made a dessert. I am really surprised because there were good reviews here! There were about 5 workers here, one should be making sure tables are clean!!! No excuses!