Food was okay. The seasonal mermaid drink was really good. But I ordered the Hot Chicken Sandwich. Which was NOT HOT AT ALL. And I don’t mean wasn’t hot enough for my liking… there was ZERO spice. You can tell the piece of chicken wasn’t tossed in anything like the description says. So I asked for a side of the Nashville Hot Sauce and the bartender brought me out a cup of clarified butter with black stuff settled at the bottom. So I added some Cholula hot sauce and it turned out fine. But definitely was not the sandwich as advertised.
I can't tell you how embarrassed I was with my out of town guests at AJ O'Brady's. I had people in from the UK. There was a service issue. The bartender wanted to make it right but the OWNER prevented her from doing so. Not only that but the owner stepped in and threatened my guests, who were being nothing but gracious about the service issue. I will never set foot in one of his places again. Avoid AJ O'Brady's and try Hot House or Alumni Club or Harvey Moy's instead.
Always serves delicious food. They didn't have corned beef and cabbage, which I can't remember if it was a special or a menu item last time I had it. I got the Irish Stew instead, which was delicious. The only issue I had was that they didn't give my wife any fixings with her Bloody Molly, which would have been nice as it is Mother's Day. Someone else ordered a Bloody Mary and got all the fixings with theirs. Regardless, one of my favorite Irish restaurants.
Pan fried perch was good with potato pancakes. Pizza was thin and crispy and o so tasty. Lots of toppings to choose from. Great family owned place. The Brandy old fashions are awesome and made the muddled way. Cheers!
My first visit and the half of a meal that we did get to eat was horrible with hair in the tarter sauce with a sealed plastic cover the no one quality controlled or checked.. When We asked to see a manager ,We were told She was busy ,although Ten mins later she approached us and We told her about the hair . our server who was pregnant only came to Us twice for the order and to bring the food ,she was neglectful and sint want to work.the Kitchen Manager with terrible body langage ,She actually said the hair being found in the food couldn't be avoided, and her staff told her We were rude to them. My companion who was with Me was African American and actually never uttered a word to the staff but was pointed at and the Manager said "You People" and We Knew We were racially discriminated against and forced to leave immediately again her Words were "You People and told Us to leave or she was calling the police. we didn't even get to finish our food.a single Man Who was a customer at the bar apologized and said He would bare witness ro the very Horrible Way We as Good God Fearing Buisness Owners ourselves were treated. We left embrassed and Hurt ,So we went to City hall and filed a complaint. I did attempt to call a. Few days later and left a message to for the owner with no response back. This is 2022 and there is zero place in todays world for That sort of Treatment of People simply because of race. I feel horrible to The man I brought to this restaurant for He was accused of being rude to staff here and never even spoke ,besides He is a Great example of kindness and respect and always helps others and has a huge following of supporters with no criminal record. I kept apologizing for the rest of the day and He was obviously Hurt and Just Frustrated. I am ashamed of the people like the kitchen Manager whom I did ask for the owner and she had zero problem telling us His Mother was dying so He couldn't be there. She was Rude and Mean and to point in a black Mans face and say You People ,I was beyond shocked. I am Irish and Italian and German and My Family Started The Wisconsin Territories in 1831 The McCraneys and I say give the Donkey of the day to this Pub.
Slow service, food is not that good, beer tasted weird when I visited. I will not be returning. The location was too busy decorating for saints Patrick’s day to take care of their customers (only 3 tables, and 2 people at the bar).
I've dined here many times and the food and service has always been exceptional. The Tuesday burger deal is a good value (try the turkey burger).
Went for the fish fry and it was really nice. Fun Irish pub booth ambiance and plenty of Irish songs to sing along to on the juke box.Fish was nice. Waffle fries were good. They served the fish fry with coleslaw that tasted like an afterthought (not a delightful one) and a white roll with a sweet butter which wasn't my jam but was good.Service was excellent. Location across the street from the falls made for a great after dinner stroll.
Great food! Great atmosphere! Friendly staff! Definitely a gem in the really cute town! The only downside I saw and it’s so minor so really it doesn’t harm the experience at all but if you get a Guinness just be prepared for it to be poured incorrectly from the tap. As someone who’s been to the Guinness factory twice and has plans to visit more in my life I’ve had the experience of being taught how to properly pour a Guinness. Other than that insanely minor downside everything about this pub is top notch! Tip top notch it’s a dinner you’ll very much enjoy!
The Reuben sandwich was great. The Smithwicks beer was fresh and awesome. The mule and white russian drinks were a little weak. The server was excellent! She was happy, friendly and had a sparkling personality. Haven't experienced great customer service like she provided in a long time. Merry Christmas to everyone at A J O'Brady's!