My first supper club experience is at Toby’sand I love it. Deep fried cheese curds was amazing and the fish fries too. First time having brandy alexander and it’s phenomenal. The server was very nice , she deserves a raise.I think this place is famous because it’s already packed by 5 PM when we got there.
Classic Wisconsin roadhouse We sat at the bar with a drink and ordered our dinner. When a table is available, you are gathered and seated. One odd drink fact is they have no tap beer- hard to believe in Wisconsin with all its breweries. Dinner is complete with relish plate-salad- bread basket- potato and entree. Both the filet and walleye we had were delicious- this place us a great stop
Great supper club atmosphere. We were there on a Wednesday and it was quite busy they probably could have used another server. The majority of our food was good but two people in our group received steaks that weren't done properly. The med rare came out rare and the medium came out med rare. Unfortunately our server never came back and asked how things were. So we ended up just taking the steaks home as left overs.
Unexpected pleasure - we stumbled upon this phenomenal restaurant that had stellar service and very reasonable prices. Such a treasure! We had the mozzarella sticks as an appetizer when we checked in - seated at the bar while we waited for our table. Waitress took our order and we enjoyed the app and a few drinks before we were invited to our table which was already set with our first course along with the traditional relish tray. Steak and pesto shrimp was incredible and my husband had the fried chicken which he said was incredibly tender. We will come back again! Thank you Toby’s for a fantastic experience! We so appreciate it!
This was my first time here, and I had their Lake Perch dinner. It was very good. My waitress was kind and the food came out very quickly. Don't judge this place by a first glance from the road; the atmosphere is very nice and I will certainly return if work brings me back to the area!
food was great! service was great! bartender was friendly good venue
Excellent service! Great food and a fun first experience at a supper club!
waited an hour 45 min for best food ever. i l was in terrific company but if the fire chief walked in 4 dinner the place would be shut down...way past capacity
I had high expectations for Toby's. The happy hour drinks starting at 4pm were good. We ordered at the bar and seated a bit after. Salad was basic. Relish and rolls also ok. Rolls not warm. Steaks were prepared just right and a good value for the price but not better than that. Service was very good.
We came here for a Friday Fish Fry and the experience is exactly what you would expect from a supper club - order a drink at the bar, they get your order and then seat you to eat - great!!! I am coming back for steak!