Pizza Extreme /Athens Gyros/ Extreme Wings

1614 Monroe St, Madison - 53711
90 reviews
Pizza Chicken Wings
(608) 259-1500

We went here after a field trip with our students. Only one person was working and not a lot of options. We could only get slices of pizza. The guy was super nice. No complaints about the pizza. If you need a job they're hiring!

Called around 5:00 for a simple pizza delivery.Scheduled arrival between 30 min to an hour.I call to check after an hour had passed, the guy tells me 15 more minutes. Another 15 minutes after the 15 minutes he tells me and I get a call for the delivery. Didn’t even bother to answer the phone. That much time passing with strangers handling my food gives me the creeps. Keep it.Terrible service. Slow and nonchalant.Do a pick up if anything.

Probably the best pizza you could get for the cost. Rugular pizzas are good and the deep dish is the best thing ever. It works well for a pizza place by the university.

I had ordered a gyro plate and I had to throw everything out. You guys might want to taste the food before sending it out. It was dry, freezer burned, and bitter.

When ordering the boneless chicken wings.Step 1. Take wings from whatever warming drawer they’ve been in all day.Step 2. Place directly into trash.Perhaps these wings could be marketed better, maybe as a chicken jerky and sold in resealable bags. Hell I’d rinse them off and take them backpacking or maybe use them as a bubble gum replacement.

The double decker pizza is a must-try and a staple of my college career! Delicious!

What a great place to experience your first college tailgate... Totally worth the experience and will be doing it again in the future....Go Army!!!!

The gyros were fabulous! Travis, our server, was fantastic. GPS took us here by accident, best mistake of our trip so far. Thanks Travis!!!

First off, the super hot buffalo wings were amazing and the workers were super nice. We asked for recommendations on the 2 pizzas we were getting and the suggestions that Travis gave us ended up being the some of the best thin crust we’ve ever had. Will definitely be back and strongly recommend this place !

I wanted to eat something fast and I thought this could be a good place. Very forgettable food and the prices weren't even that low so that's a combination I find difficult to forgive.