Fantastic pizza regardless of is you like fancy topping combinations or classics.My girlfriend and I love coming here and even though we have very different pizza preferences, we love it all the same. The dough and sauce tastes like nothing you can get anywhere else. It's a little pricey for 2 broke college students (~15 each), but it's great for every once and a while.
The pizza at Pizza Brutta is our fav, but now we have a new love! The Mozza Sandwich is fantastic! Crispy bread, rich pesto, gooey cheese and salty meat. So delicious!
I had the Miele. It was great! Crust is crispy and also doughy. I will go back and also recommend.
Came here for a quick Valentine’s Day dinner. We usually go to Novanta for pizza, but decided to try this place to switch things up.They definitely use more toppings than Novanta, and seem to use more interesting toppings as well.Everything was delicious and would definitely come back again!
I love everything about this place. The pizza is amazing. You can tell the toppings are high quality and very fresh. The only thing keeping me from 5 stars is that it's a little slow getting your food if they are a little busy. My guess is they can only fit so many pizzas in the wood fire oven at a time.All in all I highly recommend Pizza Brutta. My favorite is the Diavola.
Probably my favorite pizza overall in Madison. I'm in love with their Miele pizza -- the crust is always perfectly chewy with a nice char on the bottom that gives it a ton of great flavor. Their toppings are all high quality as well. Love pairing their pizzas with their greek salad, too -- very fresh ingredients, nice crisp lettuce, and a tasty dressing.
This is my favorite place to get pizza. It tastes delicious! Papa Johns' ingredients are borderline rotten compared to the freshness of the ingredients here. The crust is amazing. I love going here for a truly good, delicious pie.
Love pizza brutta hot good food. Kids even love there pizza. They did make a mistake with our order but fixed it right away and gave us the mistake to go! Highly recommend this place.
I absolutely love this place. Not only is their pizza extremely reasonably priced, it tastes AMAZING. I’ve never had a bad pizza there. On top of that, they have fantastic customer service as well. I ordered a Margherita pizza and they gave me a Marinara pizza accidentally (I ordered on the phone and I could totally see them misunderstanding me and hearing the wrong thing). They replaced my pizza and were super awesome about the whole thing. My husband ended up absolutely loving the Marinara pizza and will likely order it next time! Definitely my favorite pizza place in all of Madison. I can’t say enough good things about them.
I was hesitant to try the Caponata pizza. Feta, eggplant and capers? Wow I’m glad I did. Will definitely be back to have another and explore the menu. The pizza was excellent and the staff was very friendly. Not to mention the pizza was ready so fast! Also tried the marinara pizza. If you’re vegan and looking for pizza, look no further.