Insomnia Cookies

462 State St, Madison - 53703
133 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
(608) 719-3550

solid 2 out of 5. will definitely never go back. cookies were rock hard, didn’t have the right icecream, didn’t give me fancy sprinkles, cookies were way too sweet, and burnt cookies, tossed the cookie away. will never go back ever again. the icecream was okay though and peanut butter cookie.

Great cookies for a reasonable price. They were also delivered very quickly! Highly recommend

Speedy fast delivery time, amazing cookies. They deliver so quickly and have so many different flavors of cookies. They also have ice cream and brownies and cookie sandwiches. Open late and always there for a midnight craving. Couldn’t say enough good things.

Excellent cookies and flavors! They were served warm and fast!

ordered some ice cream and the workers were nice at first and encouraged me to apply as a delivery person, but then possibly gave me a fake number for their manager. then i called the store and it told me to leave a voicemail. very rude to do that.

I can’t even begin to explain how delicious their “Cookiewhich’s” are. Be careful though, I’ve cream melts insanely fast. But that’s a positive in my book. I don’t trust ice cream that doesn’t melt haha.

We ordered 12 cookies in the store the person making the cookies and taking orders said it would be 10 minute before the cookies are ready.It took almost 20 minutes and when I got them home they were all raw. I tried cooking them in my over they never became editable they were burnt and raw in the middle.

Unbelievably quick!!! I send these regularly to my daughter. I cannot believe how fast they arrive!! Delicious cookies!!!

The cookies are great but half the time they are out of stock.

First off, the cookies are great. Second if your going to advertise that you sell one dozen cookies why don't you ever have one dozen cookies available? They never have what I want. It's very disappointing. I wanted to give this place more of a positive review. But that's poor business.