Beef Butter BBQ

3001 N Sherman Ave, Madison - 53704
289 reviews
Barbecue Barbeque Caterers
(608) 640-5000

Wish there were half stars because this would be a 4.5 for me.Fast and great counter service. Having your food immediately is great. Food was quite good, especially the pulled pork, brisket and mac and cheese. Cheese curds were also outstanding. Only quibbles were the corn bread didn't seem fresh and the ribs were a touch fatty. All in all though, great BBQ spot.

Came here for a take-out order with family for dinner. Ordered the 2 Meat Plate & 2 Sides: Brisket and Baby Back Ribs on a brioche bun; apple pie baked beans, white cheddar mac & cheese and the Jalapeño cheddar corn bread. The meat fell off the bones effortlessly and the brisket was perhaps the best I've ever had and it melted in my mouth, Their sweet BBQ sauce is very reminiscent of my mom's homemade sauce so big thumbs up there. The beans and the mac & cheese were both delicious. That jalapeño corn bread was the only negative note...way too spicy and I couldn't finish it. (Sorry, Liliana's does that one best with their toned down version). I also tried their Pecan Pie which was excellent but had a very unique consistency unlike any pecan pie I've had before, but very much enjoyed it. I can't wait to try some of their brat varieties.

Excellent food, great staff, clean environment.

Ordered a dinner for 2 and received only 1 of the 2 sides and one slice of brisket. When I called to see if it was a mistake they wanted me to drive 45mins back to get a new order and that was all they could do. At 7:15pm at night this is impossible with a newborn and child who has school tomorrow. She said that's all she could do and hung up. We loved this place, but won't be back.

If you want BBQ for your wedding, do not pass up Beef Butter BBQ! They have many side options to choose from that all taste amazing in addition to the different meats and levels of heat for barbecue sauces! I simply sent my food choices for my catering request and was able to make edits as needed and provide my final guest count. The food delivery was timely and the food set up was professionally done. They have a branded truck to haul the food over and everything was kept warm! Even with the hour+ travel distance to my venue. My guests truly enjoyed their meal which set them up for a night of dancing!

If you want BBQ for your wedding, do not pass up Beef Butter BBQ! They have many side options to choose from that all taste amazing in addition to the different meats and levels of heat for barbecue sauces! I simply sent my food choices for my catering request and was able to make edits as needed and provide my final guest count. The food delivery was timely and the food set up was professionally done. They have a branded truck to haul the food over and everything was kept warm! Even with the hour+ travel distance to my venue. My guests truly enjoyed their meal which set them up for a night of dancing!

My son said it perfect after eatting here.He said, "i ate like a king"The meat is delicious not dry (pictured is brisket)We also got the pork.The cornbread is goodAnd the Mac is the best dang mac..Love the options for sweet mild and spicy BBQ

For someone who has mastered the art of smoking meats, I have very limited bad things to say about this place. The smoked chicken was good but I think it could have been seasoned a bit more (it was still good), the sauce helped it though. The brisket (fatty) was delicious and tender! The white cheddar mac was creamy and delicious! The jalapeño cornbread was amazing! The apple pie baked beans were good but too sweet for me (I'm sure most people would think they're perfect). Overall a good dining experience. I will return one day (would be sooner if I wasn't always over my own smoker)! Oh, and they have an extensive selection of uncooked sausages and brats that you can choose from. I wanna try some of those!

Such a great place. Occasionally go here for lunch. Usually get the brisket (mix of fatty and normal) with pulled pork. The side options are amazing on my last trip I ordered the baked beans with apple slices and a regular corn bread. The bbq options very very good as well. Staff is quick and friendly. Check out the freezer with all kinds of sausage and tray treats.

Omg! It was so good! I haven’t had brisket this good since I’ve been to Texas, many years ago. It was so tender and just was heaven to eat. The ribs were just as delicious. The French fries were so good with the seasoning they put on them. The staff were so nice. I used curbside pickup. It was so quick. I plan on making this a weekly dinner.