Wow! I have had Pogreba on my 'want to go' list for a while and it was so worth the wait! We had a dinner reservation for a party of 8 for a friend reunion. I had the Shrimp and Scallops with squid ink linguine (SO COOL and savory). My husband had the Filet Mignon. The 'char-crust' was to die for, and the bites were so tender and flavorful.The atmosphere here is so welcoming and very romantic; perfect for a date night or a relaxing night with a friend. I seriously love this place. We have told everyone about our experience and will definitely return again and again.Since I do so many restaurant reviews, and I'm rated "Top 10% of Google Restaurant Reviewers," I've decided to start implementing my own personal 'taste' review for each restaurant. If I like a place, I always give 5/5 stars, but the below rating will be for taste and food satisfaction alone.-Denae Tasteometer: 14/15
I don't write reviews often, but felt the need to share what a gem this restaurant is. Last weekend I dined at Pogreba with a group of 6 people, and everyone at our table felt that this was the best meal we had every had!! Everything was seasoned and cooked to perfection. We also enjoyed the drink specials and desserts. Expect fine dining prices, but unlike some other fine dining restaurants, Pogreba's entrees include hearty portions, as well as a very good size salad of soup of your choice, and fresh warm rolls with specialty butters. The atmosphere is beautiful. It's warm and elegant; high-end without being stuffy or pretentious. And the service was wonderful. We will definitely be back. If you are in the La Crosse area, and looking for someplace to dine, I'd highly recommend Pogreba!
We visited Pogreba on Valentines Day for Dinner. The drinks are well made, I can say personally the staff was excellent and so was the Steak and Lobster
My fiancé and I went here for NYE. We both ordered the special. The lobster was so good, there was no need for butter. I have not had lobster like that in my life—even in Maine! Veggies and Filet were great too. But I’m always looking for great seafood in the area! They make amazing cocktails as well!
Went to Pogrebas for the first time last night and I must say that this was the best food I may have ever eaten. The steak was cooked to absolute perfection and the mashed potatoes were to die for. The only criticism I have is that my key lime pie was very delightful, but could have used more lime flavor. It was delicious, but tasted more like cheesecake (which I love anyway). Atmosphere, wait staff- all lovely!! I will be back for sure.
Service was great...dont skip happy hour in the bar! Food didnt disappoint as always!!
The experience started with one of the best bartenders I have ever met. Now being from WISCONSIN that's saying something. The management was extremely accommodating to our needs of not having our party upstairs because of a handicap situation. Our server Ken provided an outstanding and professional job. It's so hard to find good experiences in today's world especially in the service industry. Thank you Pogreba for an amazing experience for our daughters 21st birthday party. Sorry if you are wondering about the food....maybe the best I have had I. The la Crosse area...Kudos and Thank you again.Jeremy
Poor service at bar, prime rib did not taste good. The salad and potatoes were good and waiter was efficient. Will not return.
From the moment I walked in the door, the friendly bartender started my evening off on the right foot. Barry the waiter was top notch and on the ball. My steak was Amazing. It was very tender and the flavor was nothing like I had before. Josh and his team know how to serve their customers. Thank You.
Had a club meeting in there upper balcony space. Food was excellent and servers took very good care of us. The space was perfect for our meeting.