Old Chicago

2495 S Oneida St, Green Bay - 54304
207 reviews
Pizza American Sports Bar
(920) 884-1112

A little pricey, but worth it. The server Tatiana was excellent and accommodating. Left large tip. Everything was magnificent

I was driven here by my desire for an open food establishment late in the evening. Drive-thru is hard on a motorcycle. This was one of the only options near my hotel.I had the pub pizza and some of the appetizer rolls. The food was all phenomenal. I also asked the server that night to surprise me with a cold beverage I might like. Once again, very impressed by one of the local options.If I'm ever in Green Bay again I'm very likely to return.

The Classic Deep Dish was excellent as was Zoe, our server. Lots of other items on the menu. Great selection of tap beers.

No had horrible experience today met a friend for lunch we ordered pepperoni pinwheel things for an appetizer went to eat it the whole middle was all doughy so waiter was nice took them off our bill then once I got my personal Chicago 7 pizza same thing all doughy in the crust need less to say I paid $13 for my lunch I couldn’t eat wasn’t happy have no intentions to ever come back .

Food was great but the service was not. The girl that has brown curly hair, a little lager in size, and has glasses, approximately around 5:30-6pm on March 26 2022 - sat us down on a half booth. We asked her if we can get a full booth and she said no we can’t get a full booth and it’s only for kids and larger group. In my picture not 5 minutes later she sat a couple in the booth we wanted to be seated. KAREN or not, racist or not… who knows what her intention was but i’m pretty upset about it.

Stopped here 30 minutes before closing for a drink and end up having having 2 appetizers. Didn’t have problem when restaurant closing and they tell you please lift your feet we need to vacuum. Kayla the bartender was awesome, very good drinks were mixed and food served perfectly.

I really liked the old menu. I'm not sure I'll be coming back here after seeing the new menu. I ordered the crafted beer burger with cheesy garlic bread. The bread wasn't as good as what they used to serve and the fries they have now are waffle and dont have any seasoning to them. Service was good and friendly.

service was terrible and it took forever to get our drinks and food

I promised my daughter and her playdate pizza. Paid $50 for two medium pizzas plus tip. When I got home they both said it was gross and would not eat it. I ate two slices of mine. Tasteless, with a weird chemical aftertaste. Shavings of sausage that had no aroma and consistency of rubber. Abundant cheese, again, tasteless. Everything on that pizza was the cheapest possible and had no taste. Sad. Rest in peace pizza.

The food was quite good. The deep dish pizza could use a little more sauce but overall great experience. The waitress we had was phenomenal and super personable.