Wishing Well

2709 E Newberry St, Appleton - 54915
96 reviews
Bar & Grill Seafood
(920) 734-4472

When I arrived at the bar I wasn't sure it was the right place, it barely helped to look at the sign it's so old and faded you can barely read it, the parking lot is so disorganized so that with 20 signs on the north and south side of the parking lot could double it's capacity.I arrived at 4:30 on a Friday for the fish fry it was 88 degrees outside and 80 degrees inside when I left an hour later it was 82 degrees inside, when I got outside there was a gentle breeze which made it more comfortable outside than inside.The food certainly wasn't cheap and my haddock was burnt. they do have a nice spice blend on the French fries but I simply can't eat when it's that warm so I picked at dinner for a little bit and left and I can't think of a reason to go back.

Great bar food. Friday fish is my favorite.

Friday fish fry was great. Cajun Haddock was yummy

Awesome dive bar with good service. Karaoke and pool too!

Our bartender Michelle was very nice very talkative got the whole crowd involved in enjoying the music yes I would definitely go back

Always friendly staff and great food!

Always good food!

Great food and good atmosphere would recommend ?

Fun bar on Appleton's East side with great food

Was there to help with the Alzheimer's Cornhole tournament, they were so nice and helpful, the food was great also.