Toppers Pizza

109 E College Ave, Appleton - 54911
156 reviews
Pizza
(920) 730-7070

I usually like going to Toooers but this particular one is not quite like the one I normally go to. The guy who helped me was very grumpy and did not put our garlic sauce in with the pizza I requested. Also I mentioned that we were just going to have it delivered to our hotel but that store was closed. He said they don’t deliver to the town I was staying in . That that was what the other closer location was there for. He also said it was out of their 3 mile delivery radius. Literally when I googled it this location was 4.28 miles from my hotel. These 3 towns/cities are all so close you can cross the street and leave one to be into another. So I was really just shocked that he was so rude. They also wouldn’t honor my toooers cash I earned because I had two offers for free tooperstix yet the order took the $10 off until it went to that stores payment screen and then it added it back. My usual store would let me do all of it at once. Oh well. So I rated a 3 star because I live their food, but he was unnecessarily rude to me for no reason. And did not put any utensils in my Mack and cheese and knew I was eating it at a hotel. I guess he expected me to just put my face into it. So, three stars is generous for my experience there last night.

Only place open past 9pm. Pizza was great. We went back a couple days later. Our bill came to $40+ for pizza breadsticks and soda but they gave us 50% off both times. They also had coupons on the counter which I appreciate.

Was looking something to eat and I saw this pizza place. So, decided to give it a try. The pizza and wings are so delicious.Wings were so juicy and not dry. If you ever in the area and looking for yumm pizza try toppers pizza.

Only late night open...in Appleton and the food is fantastic...don't let the awesome mac n cheese get cold. It's so much better hot. But if you do, it's a great next day lunch

The food is always good and if you order online from their website you get good pricing on deals. Only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because I checked curbside pickup and sat in my car on college for 10 minutes. I finally went inside and my pizza was ready and had been (I could see it from outside on their order screen) but when I went in no one was making any attempt to bother bringing out anything. So I would suggest skipping on the curbside pickup. I've tried twice now and had the same issue.[Edit] Nothing states that you should call when you arrive nor that curbside only applies to the 3 spots in front of the restaurant, and they're not reserved for Toppers only, so you're lucky if you get one of them.

My husband and I have really started to love Toppers' bone-in wings. The best sauce is parmesan garlic and we also enjoy the topper stix. We basically don't even order from other wing places anymore due to the cost and quality. Also, ordering direct prevents us from waiting an hour plus, or the added fees from 3rd party services.

Best pizza in town hands down, the sauce and ingredients quality is unmatched. Even when things sometimes go wrong the GM Trevor is ready to go above and beyond to fix the situation so you're always taken care of. I recommend trying or giving it another chance and I promise you won't be disappointed! Oh and did I mention they're back to staying open late daily? That last call drink at the bar won't keep you starving for the rest of the night!

Pretty much the perfect blend of taste and cost. Order is right 98% of time. Don’t charge you for little things like they do at other pizza places. Staff is super friendly. Parking is a little tight though

Topper's Pizza is one of the best pizza places, that I've been to in a long time.It's pizza that tastes like homemade.They recently added Custard to their dessert menu!!!!!NOW OPEN ON TUESDAY, all day.

This place rarely has orders ready on time and the employees are often rude and unprofessional. The employees were shouting profanities at each other over the top of a blasting stereo. Unfortunately for them, their trashy trap music couldn't drown out their incompetence.EDIT for the owner: I drive for one of the delivery services, I was picking up on behalf of another customer. There were about 8 or so employees working. The music was so loud you had to shout to speak to anyone. One employee was on the phone at the front counter when I arrived. I stood there for a couple minutes before another employee eventually acknowledged I was there. I gave him the order name, and all he said was "yeah it's not done" and walked away. I don't think he even heard me ask for an ETA because of the music.For the next 20 minutes I watched them give the same rude and dismissive treatment to the rest of the customers coming and going before finally contacting customer support on my end. They attempted to call the store to discuss the order while I waited on hold. I watched your employees ignore the phone call, so they were forced to cancel the order.I get it, it's the super bowl and it's crazy busy. However, this was a particularly shocking display of unprofessionalism.I wish you the best of luck is resolving these issues.