Stone Arch Brewpub

1004 S Olde Oneida St, Appleton - 54915
229 reviews
American Gastropubs
(920) 731-3322

My wife and I loved Stone Arch. We shared an angus burger and a portabella vegan sandwich. The Angus burger was cooked perfectly and the seasoning was amazing. The portabella vegan sandwich was very unique and delicious. The mushrooms seem to be marinated in a sauce containing vinegar and the cheddar is almost certainly aged. I had a Moscow mule and it was very good. The atmosphere and decor are really cool (see picture). The staff were friendly and competent. Lastly, the owner's philosophy surrounding sustainability and community and employee support is wonderful, and something every business should aspire to. Although they didn't have a hard cider on tap (please add a few?), we will definitely be coming back.

We enjoyed our lunch here for the most part. My elk burger was good & hubby enjoyed his burger. I was not fond of the kettle chips; they didn’t really have any taste. Nice ambiance & the service was good. They only have Pepsi products which is a downer.

We called at 3pm specifically to ask if we could place an order for pick up this evening - doing our due diligence on a busy day. We were told yes, but to call back closer to the time we wanted to pick it up. We called at that time and were told they would not accept pick up orders all day. This was our Mother’s Day meal and threw a major wrench in our plans due to the misinformation and disregard for their customers.

Great food and awesome atmosphere

Traveling through the area, my wife and I stopped in for lunch. What a great place! The cellar restaurant and bar area has a great feel to it and the in-house beer and food complimented the surroundings. The young lady behind the bar was a breath of fresh air who only added to the enjoyment of our time spent at this venue. We appreciated learning about the history of the brewery, the tasty lunch and enjoyed browsing through the attached gift store.

I've always loved the beer mac from stone cellar I don't know if this was a mistake but this years birthday beer mac was horrible! It looks like I was served someone's leftovers. I will most likely never be back. A real shame. 18 gets you not even half a sausage, a 1/4 piece of bread cut in half, hardly any pasta, and where is the bacon? Hopefully you guys stay in business serving this. First time getting a to go, if I was in the restaurant I would have walked out.

Wonderful relaxed intimate venue. Food is very tasty (pizza, burgers, wraps, etc) and reasonably priced. Even a NA craft beer! Awesome place to see a band with professional sound and good sight lines.

Very disappointed in our Sunday lunch today. We ordered an elk burger and fish tacos. After waiting over 40 min for our food it came out cold. The fish tacos had been clearly sitting for a while as the aoli had congealed. The dish was missing the rice per the menu. The elk was dry and room temp. Our server told us right away she was new so we were happy to be patient with her but the experience really fell apart. We didn't want to deal with sending anything back given the wait times for everything else. We sat for a while to get our check as well, thankfully a seemingly more seasoned staff member intervened on that. We normally like to go here before comedy shows for a drink but cannot recommend lunch. Not worth the $55.

Steve makes the best beer, hands down. Atmosphere is stellar and the beer is even better. From the historic building to a possible behind the scenes look at the beer being made, this is a must stop. The food is as good as the beer too. You can't go wrong with Stone Arch.

Natalia was a terrific waitress!!:) very friendly and fast service!! The cheese curds are fabulous!!!