Ok let Me start out with the fact that I have never felt the need to write a review on a restaurant. But this place was terrible. My experience started out with me asking for a sample and the owner telling me no he does not do samples. OK that’s fine let’s MoveOn, I settle on the cookies and cream because that’s the flavor I know and I get it in a waffle cone and it comes to eight dollars. To me that seemed a little bit expensive but figured what the heck I’m craving something sweet. Then he hands me the cone with no napkins, so I asked him for a couple napkins and he hands me one tiny napkin. So I tell him I’m definitely gonna need more than once he hands me two more napkins. I go to walk out the door and take a bite off the top of the ice cream and the entire cone crumbles and falls apart. Turn right back around go inside and tell him And that I took one bite of the ice cream and the entire cone crumbled. He then proceeded to tell me that I must not know my own strength and that it was my fault that the cone fell apart not the fact that the cone was extremely brittle and fragile, he did not offer me a new cone but handed me a cup and spoon. Never once apologize just argued with me. it was the one of the rudest owners of a business I have ever met. I will never be back and I will tell everyone that I know not to go to this place.
Came in for some late night fudge and shakes at 8pm and loved all of the flavor options and cute red booths. We got the apple spiced rum shake and salted caramel malt shake and they are neck and neck with Pilchuck shakes! The fudge is also creamy and perfect. The gentleman who helped us was kind and professional and helpful. Can't wait to return during the day to try their tomato soup and grilled cheese!
I've only ever had milkshakes from here. The milkshakes weren't my favorite and didn't have the most flavor and the total came up to about $17 for two milkshakes which I found ridiculous. The service was okay.
Best monte cristo sandwich I ever had. Tons of fudge flavors and the peanut butter cookies and cream fudge was amazing
The gentleman behind the counter was very helpfull and friendly. Fudge was awesome an so was the ice cream.
lovely service! ice cream is absolutely superb! homemade and delicious is a great combo!
Friendly Small town charm...A must visit Cafe!
This place is incredible. Complete hidden gem! The food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is opening and inviting. Staff and coffee are great as well, owner is very pleasant!
Great little cafe with delicious natural ice creams from Lopez Island. RARE parking lot and not crowded like the places on 1st street. Walk the one block for a much more relaxed and friendly atmosphere.
Update: deleted my original review because the owner's quasi-hostile reply was even more unsettling than the experience in the shop. Like other reviewers, this did not strike me as a family-friendly place despite the obvious appeal of ice cream to children. Bottom line: the ice cream here is excellent and this is probably a good spot for adults to enjoy dessert. I do not recommend taking children.