Windy City Pie

5918 Phinney Ave N, Seattle - 98103
296 reviews
Pizza Italian
(206) 486-4743

It’s disgusting to me that this company not only thinks it’s okay to medically discriminate against people, but they think it’s funny too. Not everyone can take a covid shot, some of us have medical issues that prevent it. Regardless of whether you can take one, people shouldn’t be discriminated against over their personal medical choices. You’re a vile company.

Delicious Chicago-style Deep dish

Freaking amazing is how it was/is! First time there. Was in the mood for deep dish style pizza and the menu and reviews looked very good. Didn't disappoint! And it was even better the next day. Service was outstanding as well. Forget the servers name but dude, make that move to NYC while you can! :D

The pizza here is absolutely amazing, drinks are always good, but I was actually a little unimpressed that I needed a booster shot to get in. I am double Vaxxed and very safe with my Covid protocols, but a booster shot requirement to dine in seems a little bit extreme. I was bringing my girlfriend there since she had never had it and I was super excited to treat her to dinner. She has her booster but I have not been able to get mine yet. Just very disappointing that I was not allowed in. So I took my business to Zeeks next-door.

Meh food for the cost…not worth it! Plus rude service.

Great pizza for sure but also surprisingly I got a salad I would actually go back for even if I didn't feel like pizza. Have I ever said that about any restaurant before? Pretty sure I haven't.

Favorite pizza in the city! Great for takeout. If you are eating in I advise ordering ahead. With COVID the bring the takeout outside to you which I love.

I ate here and the food was good, but clearly the staff are rude as hell and are okay with treating people like trash. I won't make that mistake again.

Legit and lovely deep dish Chicago style pizza. I also appreciated that the wine list prices weren't dramatically marked-up. One pizza fed my wife and daughter and we had loads of leftovers. Had a salad as well which was great.

I have never been to the area, so this place popped up on local recommendations. Stepping inside you have a very kitsch vibe with old school pacific northwest bar/restaurant. Packed on a Saturday, bar sitting was available (Btw Jon you our thee person!!!) The pizza was absolutely worth everything, deep dish crunch, ooey gooey cheese upon cheese, and in house made sausage and candied bacon??? I live near Tacoma and I will most definitely make the drive to Windy City Pie.. Thank you for a memorable end to the night!