Very cozy spot with a unique vibe! Some co-workers and I found this place on a Google search and decided to stop by. Excellent pie (both sweet & savory options), great drinks, and friendly staff! Seating is somewhat limited, but no problem finding space for a group of 3. Will absolutely be back again!
A bit of cleaning wouldn't hurt, but man that was the best piece of mud pie I can ever remember eating. He put two savory pies on the counter top to cool, even though I had just ate the aroma coming off their savory pies one chicken the other beef made my stomach growl. If I ever travel to Seattle again I hope they are still there baking pies I would love a piece of that beef pie.
When we went it was just To-Go. We got the chicken pot pies, banana cream and mud pie. I much preferred the savory to the sweet (the sweet ones had too much whipped cream for my preference and the crust was a little under done). The slices are large but for dinner I would say get your own.
The Strawberry Pietini is delicious! Also, of course get the Apple Pie with ice cream. The Coconut Cream pie is shockingly great.
First issue: we were given apple pie instead of coconut cream pieSecond issue: both pies received did not look like a slice of pie at all but a gloopy mess of fruit and sugary syrup with little to know crust or crumble topping. I wouldn’t recommend that it be warmed up prior to giving to customer for take out orders.I do not recommend.
I would never go there again. My son and I went there this evening and ordered two slices of pie to take back to our hotel. When we got back to the hotel, the first thing we discovered that instead of giving us coconut cream pie which is what we ordered, we got apple pie and I don’t like apple pie. My son’s pie which was Island something was a gloppy mess. Basically $16.00 thrown away. And we would have preferred to eat the pie there, but they’re only doing takeout. What a huge disappointment!
First issue: we were given apple pie instead of coconut cream pie Second issue: both pies received did not look like a slice of pie at all but a gloopy mess of fruit and sugary syrup with little to know crust or crumble topping. I wouldn’t recommend that it be warmed up prior to giving to customer for take out orders. I do not recommend.
Great spot for late night sweet munchies. The sit down experience left a lot to be desired as pies are served in plastic to-go containers and you must fetch your own water and utensils.
Great service, great pies, very cool atmosphere! Highly recommend!
Best pie in Seattle, coupled with the friendliest staff and most mood forward music selection. Do yourself a favor and stop in for one of the best experiences Capitol Hill has to offer.