I had such high hopes. I'll start with the positives:-The space seems cute and clean-Hooray outdoor dining-Friendly guy at the order counterNow, the negatives:-Bad, canned sauce-Ingredients that taste like they were fresh a week ago-Crust with no air pockets. Somehow it's new York style if you have no idea what it means I guess.-Getting this disappointing pizza 30 mins later than that their website estimated.-High price that is undeserved.Too bad. The ratings made it seem promising, but this isn't worth it.
This is our go-to pizza delivery place but I’m starting to wonder why. I’d say about 80% of the time, they mess up the order. Most recently, we ordered half margherita and half mushroom, olive and red onion. They put mushroom on the entire pizza. Not a huge deal, but my friend doesn’t like mushroom so had to pick it off the margherita side. The worst was when one of our pizzas had some sort of plastic casing or wrapping chopped up into small pieces and distributed like toppings. They’ve forgotten toppings entirely. I’ve ordered pineapple a few times and actually LOL’d because there was literally two small pieces of pineapple on the entire pizza. I always order through DoorDash and have probably gotten hundreds of dollars of free pizza from them at this point because anytime there’s a problem, I message DoorDash and they credit my account. When they get it right, the pizza tastes very good but I think we are finally sick of the errors and will try to find a better NY style pizza place. It’s also super expensive.
Only 2 other tables in the place and the service was horrible. Got 1/3 of the order wrong and tried to take the 2 pizzas we ordered away after we started them thinking they were for another table. Turned the music off 5 minutes before close. They pick and choose who need to bus their own tables and who doesn’t. Pizza is mediocre at best.
Really disappointed.... We drove up from the Olympia to enjoy this awesome pizza. When we got there the big garage doors were open and the restaurant was at 50 degrees,I could justify 100 dollars on pizza and bear for the family and be freezing cold. I guess we will try again in the summer.
I work food delivery so I haven’t eaten here yet, my order took 57 minutes since my time of arrival. I did get a free slice for the wait?? my time is money and anything after a 30 minute wait is considering extreme. This was not it chief.
Our favorite pizza spot in the area. Service is always great, and the pizza is so much better than the local chains. The Caesar salad is wonderful as well, but if youre an anchovy enthusiast like me, make sure you specify that you'd like them. Think Michelangelo from ninja turtles, but the opposite.
Carbonara pizza is my favorite. Love the eggs and garlic on it. Service was fast even with our big group.
I brought a large group of about 18 people to this venue without making reservation. I just totally forgot! The owner was very friendly and accommodating. We basically had the back room to ourselves which felt like a private party. The pizzas and drinks were also great too.
Great pizza in Ballard! Inventive pizzas plus some standards. The crust is medium thick and chewy with great flavor. It's not fast, but definitely worth the time, so plan ahead--you cannot drop in for a slice, you have to order full pies since COVID. The quality of the ingredients is superior, so expect to pay for that. You want cheap pizza? Not at Ballard Pizza Company. Delicious and flavorful and definitely my favorite pizza joint for classic pizza (not wood fired).
Unpleasant hostess. Food was ok. Lots of other options around here though, won’t come again.