I have to admit being from jersey I expected it to be like every other pizza in the area,boy was I wrong. Besides the pizza being a tad undercooked for my liking this pizza is gonna be the closest thing you get to a new york pizza. The pizza was very very good and thin with hardly any flop to it. The crust was really good as well. I have been looking for a good pizza for a long time in the area and this by far beats any other pizza place around and believe me I tried them all from here to tacoma.
In my opinion this is the best pizza in Port Orchard hands down. It's a bummer then that I can't really afford to order from here unless it's for a sporadic special occasion. Their delivery times are also pretty rough. If they could find a way drop prices and also have more predicable delivery expectations I would only ever order from here.
if you are in Kitsap County and you want pizza, go to The Brooklyn Pizzeria, simple as that. Delicious
Pizza here is awesome. If there were half stars I'd rank it a 4.5, but its a lot closer to a 5 than a 4, so I gave it a 5. If you're local, this is the best pizza place around. The owners family is super sweet. Their home made ranch is awesome. The pizza is great. Definitely will order here if I'm around the area. Only real complaint is the price. 60 dollars for two pies. That seems a bit extreme.
Was very excited to try this shop but was pretty disappointed when I opened up the salad and saw how small it was. Would it really hurt to add a little bit more lettuce? Pizza was good though. Read a few comments about their time management and making pizzas late and I experienced the same thing. Went to pick up my pizza and got there a little later than the designated pickup time and was told that they are just starting to make it. Didn’t mind waiting in my car but definitely don’t order if you are on a time crunch. If you don’t order salad and pick up late then this is the best pizza joint port orchard has to offer.
Great pizza.. price keeps rising, hours are terrible and even calling in 45 min before close is usually too late. Been closed multiple times when they said they were open. Save time and now money and go to seabeck, may not be quite as good, but still delicious and at least reliable and friendly.
Nice staff pizza over priced and was a little over cooked. Good quality ingredients but nothing to write home about. Will never go back
Being a transplant from the northeast, I have been searching for authentic NY style pizza and I think I finally found it. Delicious pizza, hope they bring wings into the menu
They might have been busy but the pizza was over cooked (cheese) and the toppings were subpar. I e. Mealy tomatoes, tiny amount of basil. Will try them again though
Super friendly guy working there. I called because I wanted to order enough food just for lunch. I didn’t see any single slices on the menu so I just resorted to ordering an entire pizza. He called me back and said he’d be willing to make a whole pizza and just sell me a couple slices! The pizza itself was awesome.