My favorite place to get pizza and coke in a glass bottle. Lot of reviews mentioning online ordering, yeah it's a website probably using some kind of online service to provide that, my advice, just don't use it. Go in and order in person and pick up in person like it's the 50's and enjoy a fantastic pizza.That's part of the charm of this place for me personally, walking down the down town walking mall like it's 1990 again and just stopping in for a slice and then continuing walking around.Of all the pizza places in Frederick County, Warren County, and Clarke County, I'd say this is a tie for #1 for me with Melting Pot in Front Royal, nothing else comes close.My only complaint is that I want fresh slices when I come in, it's best fresh, I don't want 6 hour old slices, but I won't knock any stars for that, I just chose a non popular time to come in, I understand not being able to always have fresh ready to go slices at random hours of the day.
Delicious pizza, with a slice the size of a pillow case! Crust is just the right blend of crisp and chewy, the sauce has some good bite to it, and the pepperoni was fresh and spicy. Very wide variety of soft drinks, including unusual ones like Black Cherry and Cream Soda. I always make a point of stopping at Benny's any time I am in Old Towne. Definitely worth the trip!
The one and ONLY real pizza ? in Winchester. Great flavor just like NY Pizza
Chicken bacon ranch pizza came out AMAZING!
The obnoxiously large slices are actually just the right amount of pizza a reasonable me really needs so I like their interpretation of the "slice". The flavor of the pizza is good, crust well done and crunchy, and the Sriracha sausage topping is quite yummy. Cool little joint that sells pizza by the slice. That's right, the slice. Go try it.
Amazing pizza, first time here but definitely will not be the last. Had to drive 30 minutes to get here and it was definitely worth the drive. 1 pizza fed my entire family of 6 and still had 2 slices left
Be prepared to leave with a full belly! Delicious pizza, extra large slices (two plate slices) and pie, super affordable prices! What's not to love? Not a ton of seating, so be prepared to sit close or take your pie to go.
Quick service, quality pizza, decent price. That's it.
Great pizza and great prices! Only needed one slice cause their portions are huge
I stopped In randomly with some co workers. We really had a great time. The pizza was incredible. Such a unique pizza place. Ryan was awesome. It was late at night and he was pleasant as could be.