Pycone Creamery (inside Benny Scarpetta's Pizza Shop)

1019 Main St, Lynchburg - 24504
96 reviews
Pizza Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream
(434) 528-5111

the pizza was very large, hot,and the guys were very friendly! thanks

Pizza was HUGE and cooked perfectly!! Bottom of the crust was crunchy and cheese was gooey and stringy ? 28” pizza ? Everyone enjoyed the experience!

We love Benny's and the pizza is amazing! But tonight was absolutely awful and for a reason that honestly should never be an issue. At 530 on Saturday, when multiple families with children were there, the staff decided it would be a great idea to blast music with F#@k, B!tch, Pu$$y, and Literally said the N word 37 times! SERIOUSLY!! If you want to play that then do it after a certain time and make it an adult only thing. Have some freaking class! There were several families in there that said something and all that was finally done was they switched it to a cleaner version.....

Ok pizza, terrible staff. Not worth the visit.

THE STAFF IS THE WORSE!!!

VERY HORRIBLE SERVICE. WAITED FOR FOOD FOR A HOUR . I HAD TO LITTERLY ASK MYSELF WHAT COUNTRY IM IN. I WOULD DEFINITELY DO NOT SUGGEST THIS PLACE

Excellent food and friendly staff. They went above and beyond to make sure I was taken care of. I'll be back soon.

I was expecting the pizza to be good because I have done Grubhub deliveries for others from here and it smelled delicious!!! But I have to say it took me back to some of the more authentic pizzerias I used to visit in the 80’s!! And the bottled root beer was beyond delicious!! The slice which is bigger than your head and bottled root beer cost under 10 bucks.. total bang for your buck!! I will never eat Pizza hit or Domino’s again!!!!

I've been hearing about Benny Scarpetta's for a while and finally decided to give it a try. The menu is limited -- pizza, chips, cookies, ice cream, and beer -- and the slices are huge. We had a pepperoni slice and a Manipesto slice (with olives and feta cheese). Good stuff!

The classic cheese slice is sheer perfection! Crispy base, gorgeous cheese, and delicious crust full of flavor! The pizza pie is so big, I don’t think it would fit in the back of a sedan! You’d need a truck! This is honestly a delicious pizza! Some of the best I’ve had in the world!