They lost our dine in order, then when I got almost an hour later, it the pizza and cookie pizza were burnt. The pizza had very little sauce, way too many pepperoni, and very little flavor. The best part of the meal was the garlic sticks with cheese. $22 for a $10 pizza, at best. Anyone who calls this the best in Utah clearly doesn't know pizza.
I love the pizza here. Prob the best next to The Pie. Something you should know tho; wait times are excessively long. Don’t door dash from here; many drivers have waited and given up and left. Pickup orders are usually ready 20-30 minutes AFTER the quoted time. They are consistently understaffed / stressed out / and rude.Last time in; I was in the lobby waiting for a pickup order for over an hour. While here; there were 4 tables that never received a pizza. 10 customers walked out due to the front desk telling people it would take an hour to get food. Someone with a cane was left to open the door and exit on their own and he spilled salad dressing all over the floor. The ovens were not being filled up very quickly. As the owner; you should staff up for sell this place to someone who will run it right.
The pizza is pretty good, but I can’t get over the tiny slices they cut. I know it’s their signature size at Mountain Mike’s, but I personally don’t enjoy the 2” wide pizza slices. But the service is good and they have a wide variety on the menu.
Honestly, we’ve loved Mountain Mike’s for a long time. At one point, we were ordering 1-2 times each week. Over the last year it’s gone downhill. We’ve had several disappointing orders where the pizza just wasn’t cooked right. Most of the time it was overcooked. Part of the reason it’s so disappointing is because it’s so expensive. For the price we pay, it needs to be right. And the prices increased after the remodel. All around kind of sad about our overall experience.
I got a small one-topping pizza. Picked it up on my way to work. I was very excited to use the Pi Day promo since I’ve been interested in trying Mountain Mike’s for some time. I wanted to see if their prices were worth it for their pizza, and the $3.14 Pi Day small one-topping pizza deal was my way in. When I got to work, I was extremely disappointed to see the state of this small pizza. Not only did it look like it had been cut by someone blindfolded, but only half of the pizza had cheese on it. Really bummed me out. Whoever made that pizza really screwed me over. I was a new customer and was trying to determine if their pizzas were worth the higher price tag.
The garlic bread with cheese was so awesome and very hot cheesy as well as Everest pizza. The red sauce was right on the point and packed lots of flavors. They offered varieties and combinations of toppings to create your own pizza.The staff was so friendly and kind even we came in late to order, the establishment was very clean and family friendly. There was arcade game area for kids to play. Loved their mini sized option which found no pizza place would offer. I will try their lunch buffet on next visit.
This place has a lot of potential. The pizza crust was really tasty, and they used a really smoothe mozzarella-like cheese that I've never had on a pizza before. Not sure if that's a kind of mozzarella or a different cheese altogether but it was intriguing.Would have been 4 stars but the pizza took a really long time to come out (understandable given labor shortage), was missing some toppings, and had the wrong sauce. I think it was the chicken club pizza or something like that (supposed to have white sauce, chicken, bacon, tomato, green onion), but they forgot the green onion and they had put red sauce on it which didn't go as well with the ingredients.Might come back and try the buffet sometime, and I'd be willing to try dine-in again once the labor shortages are not a problem anymore.
I love Mountain Mike’s! Their pepperoni is so unique and tasty! The dough to cheese ratio was spot on. This place also gets nostalgia points, it brings back lots of memories from my childhood in California. I’m so glad they have locations in Utah now!
I really feel bad for this Establishment! Last two times we have tried to order from there, they have not had the staff to complete our order. Great Food, just nobody to make it! Hope it gets better for them!
Mountain Mike’s is one of my favorite pizza places in the area because of the crispy cupped Pepperoni on top. We got Pepperoni, Combination and Pineapple BBQ chicken. All were delicious! Definitely in one of our top 5 pizza places in Utah.