Excellent Pizza, and excellent service....open late for dine-in great plus too....fantastic first experience here...definitely a keeper!
Ordered a 10" pizza and a calzone and every inch of the crust on both items was black. I still ate it (the toppings and such were tasty) but the level of burnt was too much to overcome the good parts of the food.
Amazing calzone! Seasoned perfectly. I had spinach and ricotta. Fan-freaking-tastic. Only downside was the staff seemed irritated or unhappy. However, the food was so good I’d go back and just expect that they are that way.
I'm a local and have been ordering here for about 20 years (including two location changes). This is the best pizza I've ever had anywhere! Lombardi's in New York doesn't even come close. The Mediterranean and The Boss are my favorites, but there are other great options.
Prepare yourself for an amazing and unique pizza. I generally test the waters with a plain cheese pizza and this place did not disappoint. Upon first bite I was greeted by a sweet and herby flavor that has a uniqueness of it's own. No flavor is overpowering and it wasn't drowning in sauce or cheese as is unfortunately the case with most pizzas. The crust was thin below the toppings but maintained a wide thick rim around the perimeter of the pizza. Despite the heavy appearance the crust was light, soft, and airy. I do believe it is the best crust I've ever tasted on a pizza. I would get another pizza here a thousand times over but unfortunately I am not from this town and it might be the only time I eat it. Sicilia pizza you will forever be in my heart.
I was so excited to try this place. But I am so disappointed. The most bland pizza I ever had. Very little marinara sauce on it. It was just like bread with veggies and a few chicken. I paid $22.00 for a small pizza and a hand full of salad for $7.00. It's not worth the money. I ended up getting Domino's Pizza. ?
For a slice or two this place is fine. The pizza tastes great. The problem is that lately they have taken down any signage indicating their price, and prices have effectively doubled from what you may have been used to last year. No 16" pepperoni pizza should cost you $28.99. Pass if you want any more than a slice.
So incredibly disappointed. Pizza was burnt, soggy, and had no taste. I will save you the trouble and recommend anywhere else, even including Pizza Hut. My loss is your avoided loss.
Had the combo pizza and it was delish. Crispy thin crust and lots of toppings. When in Salt Lake again we will be back.
An excellent place to stop and get a bite of pizza! Convenient downtown location and wonderful flavors. The best pizza I’ve had in a while! I was surprised the crust was a little sweet but that’s ok I liked it!