Amazing subs! Large portions, pricing is reasonable. It’s great to have a sandwich shop other than subway in this area. All the sandwiches we ordered were amazing, the fungi Philly was the best veggie-Philly cheese steak we’ve had. Decent vegetarian and pescatarian options. The wait is a little longer than your average fast food joint, but everything is made fresh. We will definitely make this place our regular sandwich shop!
Holy cow this is the BEST Philly I’ve ever had. Take all my money Gaetanos. Just wow. I’m addicted
So so so so AMAZING literally the best Philly I’ve had in my life. If you haven’t been here you are really missing out
Yummy food, has a few vegetarian options that sound delicious. I got the Herbivore sub.
I tried the Gaetano’s Beef and it was fantastic! This thing was loaded with meat and cheese and peppers and sauce. I will definitely be recommending this as a favorite spot in Salt Lake.
I had the Dagwood, my wife had the Turkey Provolone. Absolutely the best ! ! !
Just a great sandwich shop. They make everything tasty. This has definitely become a staple.
Best Sandwiches ever
I've had their Italian and the muffaletta. Both were solid. They make good fries, too. One of the better sub shops in SLC.
Subs are amazing, portions are large and prices are reasonable. Skip the chains and get a real sub from a place with real food not processed crap. The steak and cheese subs are delicious, the cold subs are loaded and done right. It’s all about the little things and this place does them right!