The Sweet Tooth Fairy (Orem, UT)

1064 S 750 E, Orem - 84097
98 reviews
Dessert
(801) 224-7551

50% cake 50% buttercream. It’s just too much. It is really sweet and not well balanced. There are definitely better cupcake places.

Sweet Tooth fairy - Orem, Utah prepared my boyfriend whom I Door dash to from Austin, Texas some of the best cupcakes he's ever indulged in.

Some of the best cupcakes we've ever had! You need to try these! We sampled give different flavors and they were all fantastic. The frosting won't too sweet. The cake is the perfect consistency. Price is on point; affordable!

Some of the best cupcakes we've ever had! You need to try these! We sampled give different flavors and they were all fantastic. The frosting won't too sweet. The cake is the perfect consistency. Price is on point; affordable!

The cakes pops were straight sugar and still didn’t even taste good. Very chalky and they all tasted the same, which was bad

Amazing service!! I haven't had the sweet toothfairy in about seven years and it's still as great as before. The girl helping me was very nice and the cupcakes taste amazing. I'd recommend the thin mint cupcake and reese's cupcake. It is a very hard place to find now, but the wait is worth it! Definitely plan on returning.

DISGUSTING. THEY CALL THEM CUPCAKES AND COOKIES BUT ALLLLL THEY ARE IS STRAIGHT WHITE SUGAR. REALLY BAD. SAVE YOUR STOMACH.

Went in and talked to an employee about options for catering, made a list of what was “available” when it came time to order i i called in and was told a lot of the ones that were available aren’t, fine right? It would have been fine if she wasn’t such a brat on the phone, it was hard to order and finally i got frustrated with her attitude I’ll take my wedding dessert catering elsewhere.

Went when it opened years back with friends. That time was good. Went there just today with family.... We won't be returning. Ordered cookies to split, and share.I decided to ask what cupcake would be recommended. The worker said strawberry shortcake so I went with it. The berry was rotting. This deterred my family from trying it, but not I! I cut the rotting bit off, and decided to try it. To my dismay the cake was soggy, and sticky. Then somehow as I was eating the cake it was as if I was just eating undercooked dough. I knew I would have to check for rotting berries in the supermarket. I didn't expect it from a shop.To my dismay as we went through the cookies the chocolate one wasn't cooked all the way, and yet was crumbling. The oatmeal was good until we bit into a gob of what I assume is shortening. .5/10. We won't go again.

Really good looking cupcakes here. They taste great but I wouldn’t say they’re the best in the world. I have had better but these are super delicious. If you’re nearby and in the mood for sugar then definitely stop by here! My wife absolutely loves them!