Totally forgot to review this a long time ago but here it is. When I first found out this place and had there giant pizza, it was life changing for me and game over for the other franchise pizza places on loosing a customer. This is actually pizza, fresh, and absolutely delicious!!! Staff are very friendly as well! This will always be my go to pizza whenever I’m craving it! Customer for life!
First time here and I was craving a calzone.Got the meat calzone and while it tasted fine, all the meat was placed in the very center of the calzone. That's just lazy preparing of the calzone. More than half the bites I had contained no meat. Just essentially dunking bread and cheese in the marina sauce.Also I couldn't hardly locate any ricotta cheese, which to me is the key ingredient to a great calzone. Might have to do with the person who prepared it as stated above. That person failed miserably.
The most grease on a pizza I've ever experienced. The kids didn't want it. We each had half a slice and through the pizza away. We waited 45min for this pie.If you're a fan of pizza that's served on the side of sixth street after a drunken night out then this is the pizza place for you.The cheesecake was soggy aswell.
Always a good experience. Got my pizza and drink quickly. Enjoyed sitting at clean counter and looking out at big windows at all the people passing by. Pizza slice is always delicious and filling.
Spontaneouslly I finally stopped into the Brooklyn Pie Co. The smell once again was the cause of my alertness lol I ordered and sat down with my twins to enjoy 2 very huge slices of ?. The slice was so big that one slice was cut in half for my twins to share. We ate cheese pizza. I actually added black olives and red onions on my slice and yes I ate the whole thing lol The restaurant was clean. The manager was very nice.
If I could give this place a zero I would. What in the actual heck is this ? We didn’t order flatbread we ordered pizza and garlic bread. The pizza is hard, it’s rigid and cold. Just having arrived from Brooklyn NY I can tell you what pizza is and this is not that. Better off going somewhere else.
If I could give this place a zero I would. What in the actual heck is this ? We didn’t order flatbread we ordered pizza and garlic bread. The pizza is hard, it’s rigid and cold. Just having arrived from Brooklyn NY I can tell you what pizza is and this is not that. Better off going somewhere else.
Stopped here to place a To Go order. Wanted one of the giant cheese slices that are all over their advertising and menu. It was 6:30pm. Young lady says, "oh. We stop making those at 6. Sorry." I let her know that I was alone, it was on all of their menus, and a whole pizza would go to waste if I ordered it. Her response? "yeah. Sorry. Have a good night." I rarely give a bad review. But a couple of things: don't advertise that you're "famous" for something that has a time limit, without indicating that time limit. I had gone to their website before deciding to stop there. The attached photo is from their website. So, I left. I wonder if they couldn't have suggested an alternative option? It was disappointing. The one star review isn't for the bad advertising as much as it's for the junky way their staff acted. So. If you want to try their famous dish - show up before 6. And bring your really thick skin.
This pizza is amazing. I have been coming every week for the last couple of months. The one area that could improve again is bringing the one guy that used to work front desk back. The new person is ok. However could use some training in people skills
Decent pizza. I was expecting a bit better. Nice and friendly staff.