After coming here for 6 months, can honestly say the pizza and garlic knots are consistently amazing.The owner and his family are always so kind and sweet! After trying other pizza places in the area, Brooklyn Pie & Cafe is our family designated pizza place.
If I could give 10 stars, I would. Pizza was delicious! Employees were friendly. We will definitely be back.
The pizza was very good. Reasonably priced. Staff was friendly.
I ordered through the website and was directed to "Slice" website and app. Large everything pizza and fried zucchini. After the order I received a text to download the Slice App to track the order, but the App wouldn't even open.The Pizza toppings were sparse and mostly in the middle, basically making the outer 3-4 inches a plain cheese pizza. I question the value of the pizza because of toppings; however, it was good and warmer than I expected. It's difficult to get a warm pizza delivered these days, so I expect room temp. I was surprised that the box didn't have a tamper seal in this age of Covid. I will probably give them another shot in the near future.
Was really impressed by their eagerness to make their customers happy! I was trying to make sure I could get what I wanted ordering through the Slice app but when I struggled, the restaurant got on the phone with me and took my name to match up with the order I placed. They even called me back to reassure me they were making our food to our preferences. Great pride in their restaurant! We need more service like theirs!~ S. Urbina
I’m usually not harsh for a local business, but this place was disappointing. It did look very clean inside and the pizza is alright, but I’m not impressed. We ordered 2 large pizzas, 1 medium pizza, and 1 order of mozzarella sticks and it amounted to over $100. One of our pizzas was missing a topping (which they charge about $2.50 for each extra topping) and I heard them in the back trying saying that the basil on my margherita pizza still needed to be put on - a pizza that only has 3 things on it. And like I said, pizza was pretty bland and the mozzarella sticks shouldn’t have even been served. Attached is a photo of our mozzarella sticks, half severely over fried and half okay. And I’ll pass on the same canned response that all the bad reviews get.
This is my GO TO place for pizza. Also for pasta and subs. They have the best meatballs I've ever eaten. I'm sad to say theirs are better than my own made from scratch meatballs, though not too sad since it is easier to just skip making my own. I do ask for my pizza well done because I like a really crispy edge and no doughy part in the middle. Every once in a while, it isn't quite as done as I'd like, but the fact that the toppings are done the way I like (SLICED Italian sausage, not crumbs!!) keeps me coming back. The Bolognese pizza is my personal favorite. I also really enjoy their Mozzarella sticks. I keep saying I'm going to try a burger the next time, but I end up going back to pizza or pasta. One of these days I will actually do it.
Owner was very Nice. We shared conversation about good pastas! He made me an excellent Fettuccine Alfredo with a good and seasoned sauce!Great traditional style place!!
Owner was very Nice. We shared conversation about good pastas! He made me an excellent Fettuccine Alfredo with a good and seasoned sauce!Great traditional style place!!
Yes you can have Everything!! The Everything Pizza.. That's what it is.. It's my everything! I thought I knew but I was wrong all these years. This is what homemade... this is what handmade... this is what hard work and generations of passed down honed craft is.. This is the Everything Pizza!!!Delicious, Seriously Delicious!