Beth Marie's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

1020 W Main St, Carrollton - 75006
120 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream
(469) 892-6677

Wellll I honestly don’t have a clue of how the ice cream is here because when I walked in and saw the floor was filthy and a huge cockroach on the wall, it made me wonder about the cleanliness and whether or not my ice cream would come from a clean area or if there would be a bug in it. It did smell good in there though. It smelled real homemade.

After going for my first time today, then reading the reviews, I guess it’s no secret that the lady with the glasses has an attitude problem. She acted like I was just ruining her day with my presence, even while being the only person in the place at the time. The smug-annoyed looks, the condescending tone, the snarky comments…you’re lucky I not only tipped, but that I didn’t call you out on the spot in front of those other customers that came in shortly after I was ordering. I understand not wanting to be at work or having a bad day but clearly it’s not a one time thing with this woman and clearly the establishment doesn’t care to do anything about it because the reviews date back over 2 years. The ice cream was good but she tainted the flavors with her nasty aura and I didn’t even feel comfortable enough to ask to sample anything because of how stank she was.

Amazing ice cream and their waffle cones are my absolute favorite. I do think their ice cream could sometimes be a little colder to start as sometimes it’s melting before I’ve even left yet and then you have to eat it outside. But even melting it’s still my favorite ice cream!

Ice cream was decent, but the service was horrible. Visited on a hot day with a group of 8, and after ordering, asked the cashier (girl with the glasses) if we could stay inside until we finished our ice cream. She rudely responded, “No, we need space for other people who might come in to order…”. So, we were forced to go outside and hurriedly eat our ice cream before it melted. Will not be returning to this location as long as the girl with the glasses is working there. Wouldn’t recommend.

I used to love getting ice cream from here until today. My husband and I stopped by to get ice cream and the girl with the glasses was there, she didn’t even acknowledge us. It appeared she was the only one there and was just doing other duties, she didn’t even bother to say she will be right with us or anything.Eventually we just walked out since we were never helped out. Unfortunately, I won’t be returning due to her service.

Its old style but they must be creative to make the homemade ice cream. I asked any name that I never try.

So many delicious flavors. Helpful, kind, patient employees.

Great pit stop for us with excellent service. The young lady behind the counter was friendly and helpful. She assisted us in making a great choice even though I had a challenge deciding on multiple flavors. The small space can get a bit crowded with more than a few people but the efficient staff member made it look easy. Thank you

We stopped in here after dinner Saturday night. Small shop, but the service was good and so was the ice cream. Plenty of flavors to choose from and fairly inexpensive.

Ice cream is great but the lady behind the counter seemed to have an attitude problem. Annoyed that we came in while she was on the phone and even more annoyed when we asked for waffle cones. Ice cream like I said is great but the customer service will probably keep us from returning.