Best pizza in Spring Hill! Love any pizza I get.Just try it and fall in love. Don't forget the cannoli's. Those are some of the best I've tried.I'm a picky pizza lover, I look for a NY style pizza made by Italians like I grew up on and Nellie's and Joey's House of Pizza is as close as it gets in Nashville. Joey's just edges out Nellie's (sorry) because they cook their toppings before putting them on the pie (garlic, onions, peppers).
Menus
If I have to get pizza in spring hill this is the spot to hit. I'm not blown away by it but it is better than what's between here and cool springs. It is owned by a local family and they are very passionate about the place. I will always support that. The staff is kinda and hard working. As pizza lover, huge foodie, and just coming back from Italy, I've got some recommendations. For the Bianca I feel it didn't have the a real depth to it, would love to see some ricotta scoops on it and topped with fresh basil with 1 minute left in the oven. The cheese pie was good, a little greasy imo, but not like Costco pizza greasy just a little bit. Not a fan of the big meatballs (dry in the middle) in the spaghetti and you can tell the spaghetti is batch made because the noodles are inconsistent.The sauce flavor isn't 5 star but it's a pizza joint. The calzones were a little hard crusted but i got mine at the end of the day. The caprese salad is fresh and delicious, I would change the sauce to a balsamic reduction from the olive oil and balsamic vinegar. The cannolis are good too don't forget one. I would love to see a traditional margarita pizza same style or a neapolitan style. Bottom line, ill definitely be back, mainly because of the family vibe here. Thank you for the hospitality.
A very good spot for some filling pizza. The supreme was amazing with a lot of great toppings. The cheese had a little extra something added to the crust. Could have been Parmesan.
Have been frequenting this location for about 6years and I’m not shy to say I’ve never been disappointed. Great staff, food and cleanliness. If you’re looking for good authentic Italian cuisine give these guys a try!
Excellent pizza! Double layer meat pizza was exceptional! Very friendly staff as well. Would recommend to anyone...!
Not one of my favorite places, but my son really likes it and it was his birthday.I don't like that everything is pre-made and they just warm it up. I did order lasagna on the hot bar it was very good.If you go order something fresh and hot.
Awesome pizza and absolutely AMAZING garlic rolls! ? ❤️
It was like walking into my favorite pizza joint on the corner back in Pittsburgh! The minute we walked in, Eric greeted us with a smile and immediately went out of his way to help us with the menu options. He was extremely helpful and just had a great attitude, which made the visit all that much more enjoyable. The lady at the front counter was very friendly and courteous as well. That being said, the Stromboli was excellent and by far the best we've had since moving here nearly two years ago. We will definitely be back and have already told friends about it. I highly recommend this place!
We’ve purchased take out from Nelly’s about 25 times in the last year! When everything goes well, they have pizza that rivals some of the best establishments in NYC; however, we’ve routinely experienced poor guest service and inconsistent product including burned or smashed pizza, and wrongly charged bills. A little disappointing since this could be a really incredible place if the service and care were also a priority.
We have been looking for a real pizza shop! Love the old Italian, street level, NY Pizzeria vibe! Great food - Fresh! Friendly Staff - Very accommodating! Next time, it's cannolis or bust!