Ice cream was so so good. Friendly staff as well.
Small store with great selections. Homemade! So its pretty good. I enjoyed the selection and you can sit out side in the summer and eat!
We always visit here when on vacation. The ice cream is hand dipped and so good, with really reasonable prices
Smokey mountain strawberry was awesome and a milkshake. Quick service and very tasty!
The service and selection at this ice cream shop were phenomenal! The young ladies worked quickly and efficiently. They prepared a great ice cream cone after allowing us to taste a couple of flavors to determine our preference. It seemed that all of the customers were leaving satisfied (but who could be unhappy while eating top quality ice cream?)
Old Mill Creamery is my favorite stop when we come to town. The from-scratch ice cream is literally the best I’ve ever had! Oatmill Cream Pie is their best, but you can’t go wrong with any of their unique flavors! The Banana Pudding is fantastic and the Peanut Butter tastes like homemade peanut butter fudge. The staff is always friendly and the portions are well worth the price, which I think are very reasonable. Surrounded by lots of fun shops to visit while you enjoy your cone, Old Mill Creamery is a must visit!
The atmosphere of this store is similar to that of a mom-and-pop shop. The banana pudding ice cream was just like the eponymous flavor name. 5 stars all the way.
The first day that we chose to eat at The Old Mill Creamery, we had such a delightful experience. Two young ladies offered us the time that we need to select our choices. They also provided the precisely the same amount of ice cream in the small cups that we purchased. Obviously, the young ladies were working as a team! We left with smiles, providing a tip for their fabulous service. So, the next day, we chose to eat at The Creamery again. However, this time, there was an older lady working with a different young lady. While the older lady tried to rush us through, the young lady was patient. Also, the young lady offered the same amount of ice cream as we received the day before while the older lady did not offer us as much ice cream in the two cups that she provided us. So, of course, I compared the cups to the young lady who, in return, gave us more ice cream in the cups that her co-worker had not dipped accordingly. How pitiful that the younger lady will always have to finish the job that the older lady did not complete! If your hand gets tired, you need another job. I also live with arthritis, so I do have sympathy. However, no one should be shorted for their purchase because of your lack of care, concern, or need to satisfy customers.
Ice cream was amazing and such a sweet staff member waited on us! loved the little kids table for the little ones
My wife and I went here two time while we visited the area last week. The service was very good as was the ice cream.