Phenomomal service, the young men working simply cared about the quality of the experience of every patron entering the pizzeria.Garlic knots and pepperoni pinwheels were very good. Toppings on our pizza were very fresh and of high quality. I was born and raised in NYC so I have a high standard for pizza and this place met that standard.Alot of these poor reviews seem to be from when the restaurant first opened. Seems like they've been figuring things out since then and are now hitting their stride.
Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni & asked if they would make a fresh pie since the 2 slices on the shelf looked tired & rumpled after prolonged exposure to the elements and the long ago loss of their pie-mates. The response from the back was "I ain't gonna make a pepperoni right now". I'm afraid making a fresh pie may have interfered with the staff's loud conversation & cavorting? Who knows? #typicalmtjulietservice So, it was all fun & games until the food poisoning symptoms (to not be too descriptive) hit after midnight. And thus bringing 2 stars to 1. #I'mnotgoingback. EDIT 5/3/22 The owner reached out to me and was very apologetic about the entire situation and resolved to keep it from happening again.
We ate here with some friends last night. The pizza was great. I was really impressed with the guys working there. They seemed to take a lot of pride in their work and made sure we were happy with everything.
NY pizzeria had a friendly and attentive staff, it was clean and cozy inside and most importantly… wow the food was incredible. Pizza thin and crispy with perfect crust, the salads were excellent and the wings were crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside with awesome sauce. Will definitely be going back!
Three and a half. The pizza might be the best in town. But in the last order my husband went and picked up, the knots were raw in the middle. And there was only six in one order and five in the other order. Well try it again because my husband lives the pizza so much but....
After a day of shopping I saw this conveniently located pizzeria and am so glad I went inside. The pizza was delicious and the prices are decent. Highly recommend if you’d just like a slice or two.
First time customer last week. Could not be any happier with the food, and service. We absolutely enjoyed the White Chicken Garlic pie, also you must try the garlic knots.
NY pizzeria had a friendly and attentive staff, it was clean and cozy inside and most importantly… wow the food was incredible. Pizza thin and crispy with perfect crust, the salads were excellent and the wings were crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside with awesome sauce. Will definitely be going back!
Incredible place with amazing customer service. From the manager to the staff, all great to deal with! Best Pizza in town.
I honestly would love to give a better review but can’t till ny pizzeria makes this right and we get to try it again, we have left both a voicemail and emailed them with no response. Very poor customer service. We ordered 2 pizzas one Hawaiian and one cheese steak and garlic knots. The steak pizza was slightly over cooked, had very little sauce, only a few pieces of steak and no other toppings as advertised. The Hawaiian was the better of the two but was slightly over cooked, had very little sauce, and toppings were poorly distributed on the pizza. We ordered half a dozen garlic knots they were cold and only received 5 last time I checked half a dozen is still 6.