The food was very tasty, and the place stayed super busy. Will definitely have to go back!
Pizza is delicious and on Monday and Tuesday 14" pizza is $7.00. I will definitely be going back!
Absolutely horrible. Food here is awful. An that is not just my opinion. Me and my two friends ordered a large pepperoni pizza and the garlic cheese bread that’s actually a sub roll with cheese in it. The pizza was hard as a brick at the crust and like a greasy sponge in the middle. I have Italian family members and this is definitely not Italian style. The sub roll cheese bread was disgusting it was like salty old greasy cheese in a sub roll pretty much. Remember my two friends tried this too and after a few bites all of us tossed our plates then the rest of the order in the trash. The price was not too bad around 20 dollars in the garbage so can’t complain too much there. Figured we would try it all of agree will never do that again. If you’re thinking about trying this place just be ready to throw your money away.
The marinara sauce was not good. My father-in-law ate his egg plant parmesan which had the same sauce as my spaghetti and he was not crazy about it either. Their pizza is good. I told the server I did not like the sauce. She told me it was homemade and must be an acquired taste. I ate the meatballs and left the rest. She did not seem to be concerned.All I can say is I will stick to pizza there.
This was our first visit to anthony's pizza and boy were we impressed. I'm original from NY and this is the closes I've found to true NY style pizza. Yum.
Anthony Pizza was the best. The food is amazing. Nothing is frozen all was cooked to order. The sauce is made fresh you can tell! We ordered so much food. Yes, we took a lot home. We just wanted to try and taste all. We ordered a meat pizza, spaghetti in white clam sauce, Anthony trio, and eggplant richotti, meatballs, and cheese sticks. Nothing disappointed us! Nothing. I have lived here for 16 years and I have not been in a restaurant that it felt like I was home in a true Italian kitchen! I will definitely be back! Prices are not bad at all for all the food you receive. Go hungry ? you will not be disappointed at all!
They’re costumer service is downright terrible. The owner should either A: train his staff to be friendly and SMILE or B: Fire the staff that handles customer service and hire people who’ll do the job right. Love the pizza though. Sauce is meh but the cheese is godly. Definitely fresh and tastes amazing. I’d rate it a fair 8/10, definitely better than these pizza chains. Just wish they were nice. I always feel like I’m at the dmv when I go inside. It keeps me from coming back more often. Hopefully next time they’ll be more inviting.
Not bad, okay pizza if you like NY style ( my favorite style). $8 to add two toppings which is ridiculous! Most people around here lived here their whole life so their opinions on what is top notch will differ from yours. I will say their sauce is probably the worst I've ever had before. Luckily they put very little on their pizza so the other flavors overpowered it, although they give you a cup full for their garlic knots. I love pizza sauce and always want more, but one dip of this and I was done. Try ranch for dipping. I only had a pizza and pepperoni garlic knots and would come back again, just not the next time I want pizza. I may never try a calzone or stromboli since their pizza sauce is terrible.
literally the best pizza in Morristown. Friendly staff, pizza is awesome, prices are even better. The coupons through text are the best deals I've ever saw, especially for the size of the pizza! Anthony's is a weekly thing for my husband and I. If you're looking for real pizza, this is your place. This is my favorite restaurant in this town!
hubby and I are there for the first time yesterday. ordered a white pizza. SOOOO GOOD. really one of the best white pizzas ive had. we will definitely be back.