A good solid NY Pizza place. I got two pies to go and a slice while I waited. Taste 5 stars, staff 4, bathroom 4, inside seating 4.
Initial impression: they need to relook at replacing some people. The attendant at the register seemed out of it and more interested in his phone. He doesn’t know his menu not sure why he is here… the pizza was good nothing spectacular.
I'm not going to pretend to be some connesiuer of pizzas, nor am I gonna tell you I'm a transplant from anywhere near NY. It was my first time in today, and I thought the pizza didn't immediately look great.I was so wrong.This pizza is unlike any other pies I've had, West or East coasts. The dough is thin and chewy, the sauce is perfectly tomato-y and great with the crust. The garlic knots are awesome- they dont make you gag with too much garlic or oil or butter, and they are beautifully fluffy. I had to stop- I shared a 6 piece and didn't think I would enjoy them, but I wanted to finish the pan myself!I'm partial to white sauce pizzas, and NY Pie's White slice is so freaking good that I'm going to grab a whole pie of it next time.If you haven't tried this place- dont trust yourself until you bite into the slice. Oh, and the folding really DOES help! I thought it was a joke!I'm unashamed to be going home with extra slices. This place is fantastic.
While outer edges were ok, middle was raw dough, on 2 pizzas. Staff could be heard loudly complaining about having to work, so we didn't risk taking pizza back up for further cooking.
Authentic NY style,thin crust pizza. The crust is crispy, flavorful, and a perfect holder for the traditional and not so traditional toppings. I will definitely make the trip there again once I move to Tennessee!
Went there the other night and cashier Kaitlin was so rude. She was talking about my party and I wearing masks and how we didn’t tip despite me putting some cash in the jar-which I had to force myself not to go back and grab. The bald guy she was talking about us to also turned and started laughing at us as well before coughing all over his hands just before taking a bunch of pizzas out to cut. Will not be back whatsoever and neither will anyone I know. The only nice worker was the guy with the glasses and long hair. I feel bad he has to work with people like Kaitlin and the bald guy who embarrass their workplace and coworkers in front of customers.
awesome service! everybody is friendly!! great atmosphere!
I was craving pizza while we were in town and picked NY Pie on a whim. What a great choice! Very good pizza and a fun environment too. Totally worth a stop.
Good pizza, wait was reasonable
NY Pie in Hendersonville is one of my all time favorite pizza places. The salads are good servings, fresh, and delicious. The pizza crust and the cheese are my favorite parts of their pizzas, but they have so many tasty pizzas to pick from! I recommend it 100%.