Stagecoach Place Café

4355 Highway 127 South, 4355 US-127, Crossville - 38572
178 reviews
Italian
(931) 456-9631

My last review of this restaurant was in October of 2019 and we have dined at stagecoach several times since then. The quality of the food has pretty much stayed the same... excellent. We made evening reservations the morning of. We were told that if we wanted wine that we could bring our own Looking forward to some relaxing drinks and fine dinner after a long hard and record breaking hot work day. We arrived at 700 pm and it took a few minutes for them to prepare our table. While waiting at the entrance on the lower level we noticed that the bar was completely vacant and no alcohol on display, much less a bartender on duty. At this point we realize they probably do not served mixed drinks any longer. We also noticed one of the servers attempting to adjust the air-conditioning thermostat. Our table was on the upper level across the room from the kitchen facing the platting area . After being seated it was about ten minutes before the menus were brought to the table and asked what we would like to drink. No liquor or wine, just select imported beers. we ordered ice tea with lots of ice. After a few minutes, we decided to get the Large Stagecoach sampler for starters. We decided to wait until our appetizer was served before ordering our main entree. We really enjoyed the sampler for all the different meats and cheeses to try. My iced tea went down pretty fast, our area was passed several times before we flagged our waitress down to ask for more tea, 20 minutes later a different person refilled both our glasses with warm tea and no ice. We asked for a glass of ice. 10 minutes later, she brought out a small glass of ice, not enough to fill half of one glass. It was getting warm on the second level and we were out of tea and ice. one of the chefs was checking the A/C vents to see if it was blowing. We had our empty glasses sitting promantly at the edge of the table in front of our empty sampler plates. Now we are both getting hotter, thirstier and frustrated (so much for a relaxing dinner). 30 minutes later the same person who got our small glass of ice took our empty sampler plates and said she would get us some more tea in a minute). My house salad arrives and seems to have no dressing at all. My wifes greek salad arrived and was warm, we mentioned this to the waitress and she said it was because the tomatoes are the same ones cut or out from this morning and they got hot. My main entree anchovy and onion pasta arrived, It was awesome. My wife mentioned that she saw our waitress making the greek salad at the platting area with her bare hands. I realize the restaurant may be short handed and the wait help my be multitasking to make up for the shortage.of personnel but primary reason of the restaurant is to serve the customers needs. priority of the restaurant is to serve, which includes refilling empty glasses in reasonable amount of time. If a customer has to wait 45 minutes to have their tea glass refilled it means the wait help is busing doing other things and not checking on their tables near enough. Overtaxed wait help and over taxed air-conditioning equals an underserved customer

In my opinion, the best restaurant in the area. Cindy is the best, so friendly and helpful. The food is deliciously made to order so it is fresh when it comes to you, so enjoy the atmosphere, your company, and the wonderful food that is prepared just for you. I've seen people come in and say that the food on the menu is to fancy, but it's not at all. Yes the food is delicious. Yes the food looks great. Never to fancy, so come in and try. Never judge until you try, you'll love this place like we do.

Very Cozy! Real Napkins. Food was pretty and flavorful you can watch your meal being prepared from most view points in the dining area. Chef was very careful to QC check his food before it left the kitchen. Note this is not a fast food joint so make time for that . Also a server had a "want to be anywhere else" attitude thus the four star and not the five. But honestly Good place for pasta and such!

Cute place, good food, lousy service. I made reservations and arrived to a mostly empty place which was fine with me. We gave our drink order and when I received my bottle of beer it came with a warm glass. Irritating but No problem I drank it from the bottle. We received our food which was excellent thus carrying the stars on this review because after the food was delivered we never saw anyone again. No "how're you doing" or "could you use another beer or water" or anything. This place has so much potential and left us disappointed with inferior service. Usually a place that emphasizes reservations has higher than average service and food. This place has the good food but cancels it with poor service.

I have eaten here several a l times and have always enjoyed our meal and service. Today was Mother's Day and we took our wife's for their special menu. 4 course meal took over 2hrs a lot of wait between courses . Wont make this mistake again.

We had the perfect setting for our family party in a small room off the restaurant. The server was attentive and the food was luscious. Something for everyone.

Delicious homemade food! We ordered 2 pizzas, tiramisu, and key lime pie. I can't wait to go back. Friendly service and a great atmosphere. Thank you!

I guess everybody likes pizza differant ways so I'm just going to give my opinion. The crust could have been a hair bit thicker and cooked a little longer and i ordered the house that was pepperoni sausage pepper onion and mushroom the toppings was to sparse and so was the cheese and sause but the flavor was great

The service was excellent, however, the food was very disappointing. I got lasagna. The noodles were mush. The ricotta, slimy. My husband was disappointed with his spaghetti with meat sauce. Very oily.

Amazing food and affordable prices. Key lime pie was the BEST I had ever tasted and I LOVE key lime pie. They sold 2 whole key lime pies while we were there!! The other deserts and entree's looked amazing as well. Pizzas are excellent. As was the chicken curry soup. The appetizers sure didn't disappoint.