Came down for a week of vacation and ate here. There was a decent wait to get our pizza but it was well worth the wait. My family and I thought the pizza was incredible. It had a great blend of seasonings that gave it a lot of flavor. We all said it was the best pizza that we had eaten in quite some time. I hope we eat here the next time we come down.
Ordered online while on vacation. I left specific instructions that I'd have to meet them by the door in the parking area since the building has a security code and keypad. I went down at the specified time and no one was there. No big deal. Came back 5 minutes later and am walking around the parking garage - I can smell pizza but don't see anyone. Walk back towards the door and there are 2 pizza boxes sitting on top of the garbage receptacle by the door. What the heck? No call, no e-mail, no note ... nothing.To top it off, the pizza kinda sucked. Perfectly round crust (like a frozen pizza), too much cheese, hardly any sauce. I expect a drop off in quality when I order pizza down south but this really wasn't very good and was pretty expensive.I should not have added a tip during the online order process - but that part is on me LOL!BTW, the place next store to Georgio's is called Main Slice has AWESOME pizza!
Ate there tonight and ordered the baked ziti. As you can see from the photo doesn’t look like bake ziti that I have ever ordered from any Italian restaurant in the past. There was no ricotta cheese or any normal ingredients in a baked ziti dish. What I was given was overcooked pasta with tasteless watered down pasta sauce with mozzarella cheese on top. It was served in small side takeout dish that should have been used for a side salad and not an entree. I went back to talk to manager as I told him I must have received wrong order . This could not possibly be baked ziti . I was not looking for refund I was looking to get order corrected. He told me that’s how they make baked ziti. I should have ordered manicotti if I wanted cheese in it . I showed him menu and the dish is described as baked ziti with cheese. That was his way of resolving the issue. Poor management skills and another unhappy customer.I guess he isn’t worried about repeat customers because it is a tourist area.
Sincerely one of my FAVORITE pizza places! My family has been coming here for my whole life and since my parents were dating over 30 years ago. We can’t come to the beach without stopping in! It’s an unassuming place that cranks out delicious thin crust pizzas. Do yourself a favor and grab a pepper steak or cheese steak sub as well!!
The food was good, but the guy handing my family the food was super rude. He talked down to my mom when she was being very polite to him. We placed an order online for pickup and when she told him the name he seemed like he didn’t believe she made the order and made her read back the entire order while interrupting her. He also forgot to give us all of our food, and by the time we noticed it was too late. He was rude, forgot the food, and just unpleasant. We also tried calling back multiple times and they never picked up. Super disappointed :( We had also tipped 20% because we know how hard it’s been for service workers during covid so it was another slap in the face.
Here on vacation and ordered this off of recommendations. I gotta say the Salad was awesome. The pizza, which was our main dish, I think this was left in the oven and forgotten about for someone's lunch break, then boxed and sat in a car for a few hours. The pizza was hard enough to break a tooth, literally could break a tooth and cold enough to use as an ice pack for recent sun burns.We tried calling to see if we could pick up a replacement and the phone rings, and rings, and rings and rings. I'd imagine if the pizza was cooked properly it would have been awesome as well.I would be cautious with this place since it's delivered by a third party company and you have no one to call to report an issue.Aggravating to say the least!
The pizza was good.. but the homemade Italian dressing for the salad was the best dressing I've ever had in my life! Get a salad and get extra Italian dressing!!! It's delicious!
Our family is originally from NY and are always looking for great pizza now that we live in the South. The pizza far exceeded our expectations. We even ordered an additional pizza to go! You could tell it was a family-owned restaurant and the pizza lived up to it. One critique would be making the dining area a little more updated to accommodate seating for larger families. My daughter loved playing the game machines, but they were located out of eyesight from seating.
Proper Italian style pizza. The crust is crispy and chewy at the same time. Quality cheeses and other ingredients make all the difference. The staff was fast and courteous. I appreciate the variety of hot sauces available (something a lot of pie places neglect). The only real complaint is that they use styrofoam cups.
I wasn't sure when Pizza Man behind the counter said that he was a Boston native that was Greek & they serve New York pie. But let me tell you for the for the buck and the pizza pie this place rocks I might not be the best New York style pizza is definitely the best Boston native serving New York ? ? ? ?