Stopped by here one evening around 9pm first week of July. Place was crowded, line to the door, slow service mainly because folks didn't read the menu while in line and were unsure of what they wanted. Ice cream was good but get it in a cup, not a cone. Too much ice cream piled on the cone and subject to fall off like mine almost did. Don't really understand all the hoopla about this place. It's Ice cream! Lines, dirty tables, dirty floor, noisy, you would do better to buy a pint at the grocery store. Just my opinion. Good luck
They have a Banana Pudding ice cream that is crazy good. I ate way too much of that ice cream (3 scoops). I had to visit this place twice while I was at MB
Two words - white chocolate raspberry and caramel. Single scoops are really double scoops here. Folks behind the counter are super friendly and helpful. Don't miss this!!!
We were looking for good ice cream and this place totally fit that bill! I got lemon bar and rocky road; a weird combination but it was delicious to me. They do not skimp on the amount of ice cream you get...we could not eat it all. We would definitely come back!
Excellent tasting ice creams; Oreo, pretzel and caramel cheesecake flavors A1. Friendly service, quick turnaround, clean lobby with retro/vintage decor.
Interesting Ice-Cream shop with old style deco with arcade. Plenty of seating. The ice cream is creamy and the chocolate peanuts cone, wow, very generous on both chocolate and peanuts.
GREAT customer service! They handled our crew of nine really well. The ice cream tasted great. Never heard of Mayfield Creamery. I'm a fan.
I am really close to giving a 5, but I think the flavors I got just didn't do it for me - loaded pretzel and brownie s'mores. It was high quality though, while being relatively high-priced ($7 for waffle cone), and I would definitely return.
A family favorite. We eat there every night of our vacation. Don’t be intimidated by the long line. Service is fast and efficient. The floats, sundaes and cones are delicious.
This appears to be a small non-franchise parlor but not sure. The ice cream was delicious, the cone was fresh and friendly service. You can sit inside, not fancy but clean. Great ice cream reasonably priced and generous!