Bella Italia Pizza

95 Mathews Dr, Hilton Head Island - 29926
266 reviews
Pizza
(843) 689-5560

The service and food are exceptional, wait staff courteous, and timely. This was our first time and would highly recommend! There were six in our party, we had appetizers, salads and entrees, which all arrived within minutes of being seated. The appetizers and entrees were piping hot and delicious. Serving sizes were exceptionally large and enough to share or take home leftovers.

Delicious Pizza.But we waited a long time for the food.....Waitress was nice.

Loved our pizzas. We’ll be back. Margarita had an excellent thin crust. Boys ate up the pepperoni pie. Also had a great salad with a nice house dressing. Only pizza on the island I will get.

Delivered tonight, near the beginning of the delivery window. Looked good but the fact that it was stone COLD was a killer. It does not appear any attempt was made to even keep it warm. Very disappointed. So much for trying a new pizza place here. If it had been warm ......

We had a fairly large order delivered to our house…4 large pizzas and 3 salads. On the plus side the pizzas were hot and tasted great. We loved the big slices and New York style crust. The online ordering system was seamless and quoted a surprisingly fast delivery. The negative…the food arrived an HOUR PAST the delivery window. We totally understand that HH is a crowded place and Saturday night is a busy night. But don’t promise something you (literally) can’t deliver. Had they texted us an update on the delayed wait, it would’ve made a big difference.

First not-so-good experience last night @ Bella. Mains are normally very good for us. Ordered an Italian Melt which arrived cold with burned crust. Wife's ziti dinner was burned, as well. Customers came in 10-15 minutes after us & got their medium pizza before we were served. I asked server if we were forgotten & he replied "probably" . Will go again, but not to order any sandwich. Will walk next time-

Good basic Italian fare with decent prices. Old school Italian dėcor. Some vegetarian options, lunch specials.

We went to Bella the other night and it was as good as I remember, if not better. The food, wine and waitstaff were excellent! If your looking for delicious, authentic Italian food at a very reasonable price then this is the place for you!! Great family run place. We go every time we visit the island.

The food was very good but not truly authentic. The ingredients of some items clearly came out of a can (the black olives as an example on pizza). The food was too pricey for the portions offered. We paid on average$ 30 per entree and a soft drink without appetizers or desserts. No bread was offered with oil/vinegar dip like most authentic Italian places. The place is small and the tables are small making seating uncomfortable especially for a family around a small table. Neither the food, the service or the decorations were true to an authentic Italian cuisine experience.

This is a local family friendly restaurant with take out availability. Pizza was delicious. Small interior and staff were very pleasant.