Garlic bread and knots were great. The pizza however was soggy, 10x greasier than actual NY pizza and their buffalo sauce was so hot I could only eat one piece. The cook/cashier laughed after I told him. Will not be back.
Just ordered two calzones from this place through Bitesquad. We specifically asked for no ricotta cheese to be placed inside, just mozzarella. It was clearly placed in the “special directions” at the bottom of the order. Apparently the cooks can’t read and 42 dollars was just wasted on food we couldn’t even eat. Thanks for ripping is off!
My wife and I have been patrons of New York Pizza for twenty years. (Wow that's a long time) This is the pizza that sets the standard that I judge all other pizzas against. Some came close, but most didn't make the cut. This pizza is absolute perfection.
I’ve been ordering food from NY Pizza for a while now, and being a Jersey girl. I can tell you this is great pizza/ food. I like my pizza well done,and they never fail, even when it’s crazy busy it’s perfect. Thank you for making me feel at home in SC …..Carmen
Buffalo baked wings we're cold at the center,had a slimy rubber texture?. Made them aware about it and they came back less then 2 minutes later with the same wings and I asked if they we're the same and they said no ( lie, unless you can bake wings less then two minutes) they probably microwave it which is Nasty. Also very expensive. 4 *fountain* drinks cost 12 buck's and that's without tax.Not worth the visit avoid this place if you care about your health and being over charged.( And Your welcome for the kind words ??) live long and prosper ??✌?
This is not NY pizza, more like frozen. Way too much cheese, tasteless crust. Waitress never checked up on us, asked how everything was or thanked us. Dont waste your time or money here.
If this is NY pizza, I'm a martian!The dough is bland, no taste (zero, zilch) and not crispy. The sauce tastes like canned sauce, probably is. The mozzarella is low grade and far to greasy. The sausage is little balls of I don't know what. No where in NY is sausage crumbs or these little balls.I don't know what this pizza is but it's certainly NOT New York pizza and if it was they'd be out-of-business the day they opened if they were in New York.BLECH!
Best pizza around. Really missed good pizza when we moved here from up north. Tried this place and we're very happy. Found out the owner is from Brooklyn and makes the pizza just like we are use to. If you haven't tried it, please do and you'll understand why it's better than other places down here! Prices are very reasonable as well. Won't be sorry, especially if you're from up North.
Best lasagna I've had in the states! OMG so delicious. I had the stuffed pizza my first visit and it was amazing as well. Absolutely LOVE this restaurant
Pizza was delicious but I wouldn’t recommend to dine in. Stick with to go! The service was awful! We were told they were too busy to make anything besides pizza with only 3 other tables in the restaurant. Would have been fine if we didn’t have our three children with us. We will try again with to go and maybe try some other options…. If we are allowed to order.